top | item 10909236

(no title)

Vorcin84 | 10 years ago

It sounds vaguely interesting what existing knowledge there is on people working for free for a common cause out of their own volition, and where democracy comes into play.

"Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch"

discuss

order

js8|10 years ago

> Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch

No, it isn't. You cannot put democracy itself to a "democratic" vote, that's a version of Russell's paradox.

In particular, deciding who gets to vote, even by voting, isn't democratic. The democratic decision must be potentially reversible.

nairboon|10 years ago

Of course you can. Democracy is just the ruling of a majority of a specific group. It doesn't have any inherent "higher ideals", human rights, or whatever.

Vorcin84|10 years ago

What I meant is, who do you give a vote, and what do they get to vote on?

If I were a developer, I wouldn't want to work on things that the vocal/voting people want to use. I want to work on the topics that I like. Even if the participants voted on something, it is not binding to anybody.

thomasahle|10 years ago

> The democratic decision must be potentially reversible.

So how should we make non-reversible decisions?