top | item 13454015

(no title)

cesarbs | 9 years ago

> SF school district has banned algebra in middle schools.

WTF? What's their rationale?

discuss

order

tzs|9 years ago

They did not ban algebra in middle schools. They adopted a program that follows the Common Core math sequence, which moves about 40% of what used to be in 8th grade algebra to high school algebra. It also adds some things to middle school that used to be later, if at all, such as statistics and geometry.

The whole sequence, from kindergarten through high school, can be seen here: http://www.corestandards.org/Math/

jessaustin|9 years ago

Very educational link. We're holding back the third of students who certainly should be "creating and rearranging equations" in 7th grade (frankly, who should have been doing so in 5th grade, if decent teachers had been available), for whose benefit? The middle third who will struggle to do so in 11th grade, or the other third who will never even attempt it?

Then we wonder why "STEM" employers are always trying to import labor from overseas. One doubts those workers are coming from schools that assume all children are equally talented.

yoloswagins|9 years ago

While this article on [1] priceonomics covers the issue really well, the given reason is to ensure all kids enter highschool at the same level.

[1] https://priceonomics.com/why-did-san-francisco-schools-stop-...

kelnos|9 years ago

That's the most idiotic thing I've ever heard. When I entered high school (central Maryland), I already had two years of algebra under my belt, which allowed me to jump ahead in HS, which then allowed me to jump ahead in college and take more advanced courses than someone who had to start from the beginning would have had time for.

This is ridiculously short-sighted.

cesarbs|9 years ago

Ugh. So sad. Essentially disincentivizing higher performing kids from getting ahead. Hope I never have to deal with that in our school district.