top | item 13773846

(no title)

gnipgnip | 9 years ago

To be fair, the Wikipedia sites for these languages barely have any content. Of those that do exist most articles are essentially 2-line blurbs. These languages are essentially dead for all practical purposes.

discuss

order

lovich|9 years ago

Calling a language with hundreds of millions of speakers "dead" because their wikipedia articles aren't fleshed out seems a bit hyperbolic

gnipgnip|9 years ago

I'm not going to waterdown my analysis for some two bit politically correct occidentals and "hyper-nationalist" orientals.

A large fraction of Indian children will be illiterate in these "thriving" languages in the coming decades, with "zero" monetary loss. Not living is death, and they haven't been alive for a long time - I can neither get any Govt. services in my mother tongues, nor can get the laws done by the colonial state in Delhi.

A zombie is not alive IMO. If Indians wish to parlay their tongues for money, it's upto them. I for one will not deceive myself. We are going to be part of the borg that is the Anglosphere in less than 3-4 generations.