top | item 13960253

(no title)

vinceyuan | 9 years ago

One solution in my mind is the source code of the monitoring software must be reviewed by independent and trusted software engineers/experts.

discuss

order

effie|9 years ago

... and everybody who uses a different software not approved by state will be flagged as a criminal. This will make the job of police and spooks easier, we know there was order and security in East Germany or other countries of the Soviet block.

Now consider the cost of such 'solution'. Free speech gets redefined, most of the people get divided into informants,opportunists, naive state suckers and silent fragmented opposition. Is that kind of security and police state an acceptable cost? For preventing small number of violent deaths each year?

There are much bigger problems in Western societies than a bunch of lunatics killing small number of people, but those can't be used so easily to make a power grab.

AsyncAwait|9 years ago

How do you ensure that what was the reviewed source is what is actually being used? Also, how do you encode in source code who is the correct target to use this against, for now and in the future?

ktta|9 years ago

That's a perfect solution actually. But sadly, we aren't there just yet. There are nuances with these things that software can't (yet) pickup.

So humans have to do it till then. We were maybe born too early. But I think it makes things interesting.

That means there are still problems for you and me to solve.

natch|9 years ago

Actually it's a horrible non-solution.

Assuming these experts are perfect and infallible (a bad assumption), then what does it prove?

That only an authorized government agent can have access?

Can you not think of any problem with that whatsoever?