top | item 15747736

(no title)

jaspervdj | 8 years ago

Explanation in this comment: https://github.com/bountysource/core/issues/1147#issuecommen...

  On July 27, we reached out to Bountysource in response to a complaint we
  received from a user. During our investigation and discussions with members of
  your team, we found that your organization does not have a mechanism for
  responding to removal requests from users, which is required by our Terms of
  Service. Specifically, Bountysource does not "respond promptly to complaints,
  removal requests, and 'do not contact' requests from GitHub or GitHub Users."
  Over two months later, you have not made any changes to your platform in
  response to our requests.
  
  Therefore, we have suspended your application until you create a process for
  actively responding to all personal information removal requests, including
  those related to projects and issues. In order for us to remove the
  suspension, we would ask to see two things:
  
  1. Confirmation from you that you have a process in place for responding to
  takedown requests about all areas of your website.
 
  2. Inclusion of a public notice to your users stating how to request the
  removal of information. That notice can be included in your documentation or
  other legal notices.
  
  Once you have that process and public notice in place, we'll be happy to
  review your site and consider lifting the suspension.
Sounds like it's (hopefully) not permanent.

discuss

order

wonderous|8 years ago

For mobile users [1], quote above:

“On July 27, we reached out to Bountysource in response to a complaint we received from a user. During our investigation and discussions with members of your team, we found that your organization does not have a mechanism for responding to removal requests from users, which is required by our Terms of Service. Specifically, Bountysource does not 'respond promptly to complaints, removal requests, and do not contact requests from GitHub or GitHub Users.' Over two months later, you have not made any changes to your platform in response to our requests.

Therefore, we have suspended your application until you create a process for actively responding to all personal information removal requests, including those related to projects and issues. In order for us to remove the suspension, we would ask to see two things:

1. Confirmation from you that you have a process in place for responding to takedown requests about all areas of your website.

2. Inclusion of a public notice to your users stating how to request the removal of information. That notice can be included in your documentation or other legal notices.

Once you have that process and public notice in place, we'll be happy to review your site and consider lifting the suspension.”

[1] Please don’t use CODE-SNIPPET formatting to quote text, it is unreadable on mobile.

jordigh|8 years ago

> Please don’t use CODE-SNIPPET formatting to quote text, it is unreadable on mobile.

I don't use mobile, can you show us what does it look like? Is there a maximum width that works?

HN doesn't offer a lot of markup and indenting text for monospacing is about the only tool that they offer for code snippets.

nwah1|8 years ago

Seems like this is just a bug that HN should fix.

Sir_Cmpwn|8 years ago

As someone who does not want BountySource involved in their open source projects, I applaud GitHub for this move. IMO BountySource is a borderline bad actor. It was a pain in the ass to get them to remove my projects from their platform and then they only "sort of" did.

eganist|8 years ago

Since reading comprehension is apparently a challenge:

Accusation

> IMO BountySource is a borderline bad actor.

Elaboration

> It was a pain in the ass to get them to remove my projects from their platform and then they only "sort of" did.

Sir_Cmpwn has no further obligation to elaborate even further on the detail given, though there might be a benefit to explaining what "'sort of' did" means.

Edit: looks like he did here anyway -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15748433

MadcapJake|8 years ago

Would you care to elaborate on "borderline bad actor"?

em3rgent0rdr|8 years ago

In what ways is BountySource a "bad actor"?