top | item 15764530

Station X Linux Machines

189 points| infodroid | 8 years ago |stationx.rocks | reply

169 comments

order
[+] kkarp|8 years ago|reply
Next reseller of the same OEM laptop ordered somewhere in China.

Check the right side of this laptop: https://stationx.rocks/products/spitfire

and compare with Galago pro: https://system76.com/laptops/galago

sides: https://screenshots.firefox.com/0I2YsDmIvbKuYbr3/stationx.ro... and https://d1vhcvzji58n1j.cloudfront.net/assets/products/galp3/...

and I've seen this model at least on two other resellers.

[+] babaganoosh89|8 years ago|reply
Seems like they’re dreaming if they expect someone to buy an $1000+ laptop from a company they’ve never heard of.
[+] ulkesh|8 years ago|reply
The reason these look similar to System76 is because they are the exact same Clevo chassis. The bezels are awful, but I give credit to System76 and Station X and any other that works to sell and maintain Linux machines.

My next Linux laptop may be from one of these companies if they can work with Clevo to stop making the screen bezels so horrendously large.

[+] qubex|8 years ago|reply
Aside:

Station X was the wartime codename for the Bletchley Park facility where (amongst others) Alan Turing worked on breaking German Enigma-enciphered traffic and Tommy Flowers built the Colossus electronic calculator for breaking encrypted teleprinter codes (Geheimscriber).

All the laptops are named after WW2-era fighter planes. The desktop is named after a long-range wartime strategic bomber.

[+] caterama|8 years ago|reply
Looks similar to https://system76.com/.

I got the 17" Kudu for work. Honestly, I'm now aware that a 17" screen on a laptop is just too impractically big, but the hardware has been great.

[+] alex_duf|8 years ago|reply
14" is perfect size for me. Not 13", not 15" but 14". I hope it will become easier to find in the future.
[+] vidarh|8 years ago|reply
A 17" laptop is great for working from the couch, and that's what I use it for. It's not so great as an actual portable computer, so I've coupled it with an 11" that I carry with me for meetings etc...
[+] wildmusings|8 years ago|reply
Having a big screen is so nice. The 17” MacBook Pro is the second best computer I ever had, after my current Thinkpad T530. If I had to buy a new computer today (hopefully not, as my Thinkpad is still going strong at five years old), I’d probably go for the P70.

I don’t mind having a big and heavy laptop though. I carry it in a backpack, and a few pounds more or less on my back is pretty insignificant.

[+] brightball|8 years ago|reply
I’ve been very happy with my 17” Dell Precision 7710. But I wanted a big screen and a laptop with lots of ports, room for 2 hard drives, etc.
[+] edent|8 years ago|reply
Entroware also resell these laptops - at a better price - https://www.entroware.com/store/laptops

All I want from my next laptop is to be powered via USB-C. I'm sick of dragging around multiple different chargers for my gadgets.

[+] larelogio|8 years ago|reply
Powered by USB? Isn't that a different class of machine? Apple has the Book/Air but not the Pro.
[+] Coding_Cat|8 years ago|reply
Price-wise they seem quite competitive on paper. I'm curious as to what the build quality & peripherals are like. In my experience the real difference between a regular and top-of-the-line laptop is in the small things.

They're also lacking a 4k laptop, which I would highly recommend to anyone used to working on the road. (or who has to show of work to clients in person).

[+] rplnt|8 years ago|reply
Why the keyboard layout? End next to up key? Insert above backspace? What's wrong with the classic 2x3 block?

Another issue I have is with the spacing between F keys. Looks like an afterthought to Fn+? keys.

Not to mention there is not a single clear picture of the keyboard on the product page...

https://stationx.rocks/products/manjaro-special-edition-spit...

[+] robin_reala|8 years ago|reply
Also the slight irony of “We create drop-dead gorgeous machines - designed and customised to run Linux - and only Linux” next to a photo of a machine with a Windows key.
[+] diggan|8 years ago|reply
Regarding "End next to up key", it's the same as on the Carbon X1 which to be honest, is kind of comfortable. I'm using the arrow keys to scroll on pages when reading, and when I want to skip, the keys for that is right next to it.
[+] rst|8 years ago|reply
Product customization screen has multiple keyboard layouts; "USA English" is not the default, and probably not what's in the shots (though I'm not sure where you can see what it does look like)...
[+] gravypod|8 years ago|reply
The only laptop I would consider upgrading to from my Thinkpad X220 would either be a modern Thinkpad x270 (just for a hardware upgrade because I like the form factor) or to something that provides a similar keyboard, docking, and modern-ish hardware.

Most of my work happens over SSH, my laptop is currently fast enough for Netflix, email, and web browsing. I'm capped at 2 1920x1080 monitors but this is livable.

I think if someone took the old X220 generation Thinkpads, upgraded the internals, and kept the keyboard and docking that they would sell like hotcakes.

[+] bitonico|8 years ago|reply
Somebody _is_ kind of doing that: https://geoff.greer.fm/2017/07/16/thinkpad-x62/ . They also mod x220s but the mod is more invasive since they require a different screen bezel.

I recently got an x62 and it's great, although you must put some effort into making linux work smoothly on it and making the screen brighter. But all in all I am extremely happy with it.

[+] partycoder|8 years ago|reply
I dislike the website. The reasons are:

1. "Beautiful machines" is the first point being made. This is superficial.

2. "All distros welcome". Turns out that installing a distro is the least of my concerns when it comes to a laptop.

3. The first thing you notice is this video with the multiethnic group of people from which one of them is at the front as well as happier/dancing. This is inconsistent and weird. What is the message being communicated with this? How is it relevant? Sell me a goddamn laptop instead. Put a picture of a laptop or something.

In order to be constructive, what I would rather emphasize is: laptops are hardware. The intended audience here are tech enthusiasts. I would rather speak about hardware specs, or something distinctive about the hardware, compatibility, the ergonomics... post a benchmark. Something that is actually better than "beautiful laptops" and a awkward video. This is common sense.

This is how a system is sold: https://www.apple.com/imac-pro/ . Note: I do not own one and I am not affiliated with that company, just making a point.

Then... just a reminder: most laptops are potentially a Linux laptop.

[+] toyg|8 years ago|reply
> Turns out that installing a distro is the least of my concerns when it comes to a laptop.

Man, how times have changed. Linux working half-decently on a laptop used to be the holy grail of opensource fans. Nowadays, thanks to Ubuntu and friends, chances are that most of it will just work, regardless of hardware. This is a massive achievement and it's not really as promoted as it should be.

[+] bwindels|8 years ago|reply
> We create drop-dead gorgeous machines - designed and customised to run Linux - and only Linux.

Only linux? Seems like a weird limitation... or am I understanding this wrong?

[+] 8draco8|8 years ago|reply
Don't want to sound rude but: "created"? Or just resold whatever Compal/Clevo are building with hand picked some components like WiFi card that happen to have drivers in Linux kernel?
[+] 8draco8|8 years ago|reply
One more thing:

> designed and customised to run Linux - and only Linux.

But super key still have Windows logo.

[+] snvzz|8 years ago|reply
>and only linux

Because, screw bsd users.

Then there's the model that's branded "for manjaro", a distribution that almost nobody cares about and that every arch user will sneer at.

They could get a clue. At least try to understand the target market.

[+] icebraining|8 years ago|reply
I think they mean "only designed and customized for Linux", not that it can't run other stuff. Essentially the same as 99% of laptops, except for Linux instead of Windows :)
[+] jabl|8 years ago|reply
> We are Linux advocates who believe in providing you the most free and open devices to create your most important work.

Does that mean they have a disabled/cleaned ME like the purism machines? Or what does "free and open" mean in this case?

[+] Shelnutt2|8 years ago|reply
On the "free and open" front, their "B-29 Superfortress" linux desktop only has options for Nvidia graphics cards. Would have been nice to see some AMD options in support for their open source work.
[+] tankenmate|8 years ago|reply
To quote Fawlty Towers, "Don't mention the graphics card!"
[+] dre85|8 years ago|reply
Are they intentionally trying to optimize bezel real estate? Like for people who add a lot of post-its to the side of their screens?
[+] snorremd|8 years ago|reply
If Linux people are known for anything it's their love of post-it notes on the side of their screen /s. But yeah. If I wanted a "gorgeous Linux laptop" I would buy a Dell XPS 13". Dell actually puts some work into making their own hardware and they upstream drivers and other stuff so the XPS actually works pretty well with Linux.
[+] lerie82|8 years ago|reply
Just buy and powerwash a Chromebook.
[+] 52-6F-62|8 years ago|reply
Seriously I wonder why not this? I understand if you're looking for a portable workstation or something of that performance why not... but for an ultra-portable little dev machine. And it would be far cheaper, too, no?

(I've liked what System76 has done, but even then I probably wouldn't spring for the Galago as opposed cheaper Chromebook unless I were jumping up to one of their other workhorses)

[+] linopolus|8 years ago|reply
> Gorgeous Linux laptops

First thing I noticed on these pictures, was the ugly sticker left side underneath the keyboard. Sorry, but such trifles got nothing to do with gorgeous. Also, black camera frame, huge display bezel, and non-centered touchpads are, imho, a nogo if you wanna call it gorgeous.

[+] dingo_bat|8 years ago|reply
I prefer the touchpad not to be in centre. It does not make any sense. It's like putting your mouse in the middle of your desk, instead of the right or left where you can actually hold it properly.
[+] osullivj|8 years ago|reply
I had been planning to replace my faithful 5yr old Samsung Ultrabook with a Dell XPS. But I like the idea of buying from a UK supplier based in Bletchley Park and using a lot of WWII branding. I do need a win32 dev env, but I guess I could run Windows inside a VM.
[+] toyg|8 years ago|reply
> using a lot of WWII branding

Yeah tbh that's the only thing that puts me off a bit. War is war, I'd rather not glorify it; it might be a necessary evil on occasions, but I'd rather not be reminded of that every day. Then again, I'm not British.

Still, I would expect the subset of potential buyers for geeky machines not to massively overlap the nationalistic subset of the British population, so to me it looks like poor marketing overall.

[+] jorgemf|8 years ago|reply
"By Linux nerds for Linux nerds." and all the people in the picture are guys with glasses a couple of man from different nationalities. Thanks for the stereotype. Women in tech are going to be very proud of this image.
[+] walsk|8 years ago|reply
I'm sorry (and I'm so called woman in tech, if any), but shouldn't girls worry about WomenInTech trend?

If everyone makes you a way because you're a Woman, not a good engineer - is there anything good about this?

Who cares about the picture, if these guys make nice laptops?

[+] dirtyqwerty|8 years ago|reply
As a woman in tech (20+ years), I can say this definitely rankled with me. 2005 called and wants its metrosexual dudebro brogrammer stock photographs back.
[+] phaemon|8 years ago|reply
Is there anyone here who's actually used one of these?
[+] sspiff|8 years ago|reply
No, but I can tell they're just rebranded Clevo builds.

These machines have very decent specs and are easy to service and upgrade, but at the cost a of very low quality build with regards to the laptop case itself.

There are plenty of other brands that offer the same kind of Clevo laptops with Linux, the best known of which is system76.

Basically, these are just the same Clevo machines you can buy with any Clevo reseller, but with Linux installed for marketing differentiation, and a significant mark up in pricing.

[+] upofadown|8 years ago|reply
> designed and customised to run Linux - and only Linux.

So no BSD then?

[+] freedomben|8 years ago|reply
I interpret that to mean, "We only focus on whether this thing works well with Linux." So BSD may work fine, but YMMV.
[+] peterisza|8 years ago|reply
"Battery life: up to 5 hours".

Not a MacBook Pro killer at all.

[+] JustSomeNobody|8 years ago|reply
I read that and came to say the same. Not sure if this is because of Linux power management or the hardware itself. Either way I don't consider any laptop with "up to 5 hours" battery life an option anymore. I keep laptops longer and batteries degrade over the years.