top | item 16570402

(no title)

gort | 8 years ago

Given how well-suited our universe seems to be for life, I feel like we should admit that one of 2 things is true...

(1) There is a God who decides how things are.

(2) Many universes exist.

Actually I usually feel that the second is simpler than the first, despite my prejudices as a near-Catholic. But I'm increasingly skeptical about efforts to maintain that there's only one, unplanned, universe.

discuss

order

lysium|8 years ago

It really looks like some miracle that our universe allows life, but I don't think there is any effort: I can only write this comment because I live in a universe that allows life.

It's like marveling about how come that those two (great/ugly/wonderful/annoying/...) people are my parents, given that there are so many people in this world. What are the odds?

gort|8 years ago

"I can only write this comment because I live in a universe that allows life."

Sure; but my point is, it's really quite unlikely that the one and only unplanned universe would have life, at all. Life then seems like evidence for something...

"It's like marveling about how come that those two [...] people are my parents"

By contrast, I'm not sure what that would be evidence about.

ggg9990|8 years ago

But our universe isn’t well suited for life, our planet is.

So 1) there is a god or 2) many planets exist.

gort|8 years ago

"But our universe isn’t well suited for life, our planet is."

I suggest that most possible universes would have zero regions containing life.