top | item 17549025

(no title)

throwawayqdhd | 7 years ago

Mozart was writing symphonies by this age. Prodigies exist in every field.

Is there a geographical bias in your skepticism? Would you be as skeptical if this kid was from Norway or Sweden or Austria?

discuss

order

xtrapolate|7 years ago

> "Is there a geographical bias in your skepticism? Would you be as skeptical if this kid was from Norway or Sweden or Austria?"

Nothing in the parent comment implies a so-called "geographical bias", yet there you are accusing them of being racist.

coldtea|7 years ago

"Implies" means it doesn't have to be spelt out -- it can linger below the surface.

And whether implied or not, it's a legitimate question to ask. E.g. if the kid was asian would as many have the same suspicion given the same evidence (or lack thereof)?

nkrisc|7 years ago

> Would you be as skeptical if this kid was from Norway or Sweden or Austria?

Yes, I would be. I'm sure many people would still be skeptical.

frockington|7 years ago

> Prodigies exist in every field As proof you mentioned Mozart who two centuries ago in Europe. I am skeptical on a geographical and time level based on your evidence

drcode|7 years ago

What a horrible comment... I hope you're just having a bad morning and will feel guilty about it after you've had your morning coffee :-)

coldtea|7 years ago

Because everybody is a good soul, and can't possible have a racial bias?

Or what's more, because somebody can not be racist and still have a racial bias?

ihsw2|7 years ago

There's nothing wrong with having a geographic bias in skepticism, Nigeria is not a historical source of innovation.

This is not necessarily a bad thing, if anything it elevates this boy's achievements even more and puts his talents in the realm of once-in-a-thousand-generations.