top | item 18577890

(no title)

TimJYoung | 7 years ago

Absolutely - adding money doesn't automatically result in trustworthiness. What it does do, however, is make the transaction fall under legal commerce, which gives the purchaser/user rights and remedies that they do not have with free (as in cost) software.

With foundations or any other form of over-arching bureaucracy, you risk stultifying software developers and harming innovation. It's really, really hard to beat the self-organizing aspects of free markets combined with commercial legal frameworks.

discuss

order

skybrian|7 years ago

Well okay, but these aren't opposites. Large businesses cooperate internally using bureaucracy. They cooperate externally using (and funding) foundations and other open source work.

There is market demand for stability and it can be a competitive advantage over innovative but unstable alternatives. (Consider why Go and Docker are so popular.)

And why do companies start and fund foundations? Because their customers have doubts. It's better for stability than a market that's not based on standards.