top | item 21354938

(no title)

lightbyte | 6 years ago

Gender identity is an emergent social construct, there isn't anything biological about it.

discuss

order

astine|6 years ago

The distinction between a social construct and biology is artificial. Reading and writing are a social construct but learning to read and write at a young age has a profound impact on your brain structure.[1] I think what you mean to say is that there is no instinctual sense of gender identity that people are born with... that it is purely a learned identity. I'm not certain that is true as gender distinctions are pretty deeply ingrained nearly every culture around the world including most hunter-gather cultures, (The exact extent and nature of the distinction varies, but mere existence of an distinction is close to a constant.) and there is reason to believe that the sexual division of labor was key to the evolution of human sociality, which would make gender identity distinction hundreds of thousands of years old at the youngest. I'd be interested in any studies demonstrating that there is no instinctual component.

1. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23273798.2018.1...

rpmisms|6 years ago

Besides the concepts of motherhood and fatherhood. Ignoring those glaring omissions, you're closer to having a point.

dahart|6 years ago

The parent is completely correct, why are you fighting it? This isn’t something you can out-logic, the words have definitions. Sex is the biological part and gender is the social & cultural aspects of sex.

conanbatt|6 years ago

If there is nothing innate to the human on Gender identity, if its purely a construct, then you can engage in full repression of gender identities with no consequences.

lazyasciiart|6 years ago

Weird, doesn't seem to work that way with religion.