top | item 21429908

Microsoft Reveals New Logo for Microsoft Edge

63 points| meed | 6 years ago |thurrott.com

74 comments

order

mxfh|6 years ago

As far as analogies go, I think it's closest to the chromium logo [1], when kinematically interpreted as some sort of extruding shell segments [2], or blades of an aperture (Aperture Science). Overall it's visual language elements are surely intentionally aligned well centered in a space between IE ℮, Chrome and Firefox.

[1] current: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Chromium_11_Logo.svg

[2] old chromium(2009-2011): https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Chromium_Logo.svg https://codereview.chromium.org/2806029/patch/1/61

lucideer|6 years ago

The Chromium logo is angular and defined, whereas Firefox/Edge both represent fluid waves sweeping circularly.

The Chromium logo is in bluish tones, and is somewhat ring/donut shapes, and beyond those two (very broad) features there are no further similarities.

See also the Firefox ecosystem logo: http://ffp4g1ylyit3jdyti1hqcvtb-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/open...

and even more striking, some of the mocks from Mozilla's design docs for future Firefox products https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/11896715/S...

galonk|6 years ago

So, like... does EVERYONE think it looks too much like the Firefox logo, or...

mehrdadn|6 years ago

Nope, I think it's a lot more like Chrome's.

tobr|6 years ago

That was my first thought. I’m sure I’ve seen some unsolicited re-design of the Firefox icon that looked very similar to this, but with an orange palette.

chrisseaton|6 years ago

Doesn't really look like a fox to me. Maybe a tadpole?

wayneftw|6 years ago

I hope they have as much success with this as they've had with VS Code and I'm looking forward to trying their first release of Edge on Linux. It will be great to have the choice of a non-Google, WebKit based browser from a major distributor who has the resources to keep up with and challenge Google on things like Manifest v3.

I find it somewhat ironic that the most used software I'm running on my Linux desktop, VS Code, is a free and open source Microsoft product. It's also the product that really enabled me to make the switch in comfort. Maybe soon though I'll be using Bing more too (among others like DDG) if Google decides to completely remove URLs from search result links.

Osiris|6 years ago

I use Vivaldi on Linux, macOS, and Windows. It's the most customizable browser I've used since Opera 12 (which makes sense, since one of the Opera founders started Vivaldi).

zapzupnz|6 years ago

Edge is based on Blink, not WebKit. Remember that Blink was forked from WebKit six years ago. In web time, that might as well be a century, given the leaps that have been made in web tech in browsers.

saber1|6 years ago

The new Edge is based on Chromium (Uses Blink as the engine), so I don't think it will challenge Google on things like Manifest v3.

the_pwner224|6 years ago

Falkon is the KDE browser which is WebKit-based and not Google. It works on at least Linux and Windows. I believe the GNOME browser (Epiphany?) is also WebKit-based.

reichardt|6 years ago

I believe Edge is based on Chromium not WebKit?

ravenstine|6 years ago

The further they can move away from the legacy of Internet Explorer, the better.

lostgame|6 years ago

I only remember IE fondly from my early days of using it on OSX and Classic MacOS.

For Windows it always seemed like Netscape worked better into Firefox came along.

gen3|6 years ago

I can totally see this confusing less technically literate people. I think too many people are trained to just click the blue E.

I think I do like it. I think it fits what Microsoft is trying to do with their design scheme.

cm2187|6 years ago

It's the "c" of Chredge, isn't it?

RcouF1uZ4gsC|6 years ago

If you rotate 180 degrees up, it looks like a “G” which I guess is appropriate as it is based on Chrome’s rendering engine.

code4tee|6 years ago

Looks mostly like the Firefox logo

mixmastamyk|6 years ago

I don’t hate it, kinda cool actually, but missing something. Perhaps text.

theclaw|6 years ago

I’m not sure I’m a fan. It’s like a profile shot of a laughing bulbous head. It says supermarket brand laundry detergent to me.

saghm|6 years ago

> It says supermarket brand laundry detergent to me

I didn't think of this before, but I don't think I'll ever be able to unsee this now

51Cards|6 years ago

Well now if you're colour blind you may not know if you're clicking on Firefox or Edge.

ricc|6 years ago

Most comments say it either looks like Firefox’s logo or Chrome’s. I think it’s kinda both.

cryptozeus|6 years ago

Good logo but that is not going to have anyone start using edge. They offer nothing new. I think brave is far better and innovative browser if anyone wants to try something different then chrome or FF.

thrower123|6 years ago

Having a good, standards compliant browser with active development by default will be something I'll much appreciate. I hope this makes it to Windows Server; I am so sick of only being able to use the extra-locked down, terrible version of IE when I have no other choice but to use a browser when remoted into a box.

adrift|6 years ago

It looks very underwhelming and lacks personality.

vidanay|6 years ago

The logo, or Edge?

aklemm|6 years ago

It screams “impending doom” to me.

hpoe|6 years ago

I thought they were replacing edge with Blink soon?

lucideer|6 years ago

They're replacing EdgeHTML (the internal engine within Edge) with Blink (the internal engine within Chromium). The name of the overall Edge product isn't changing (to my knowledge).

burmer|6 years ago

Microsoft reveals new browser for Microsoft Edge.

seemsridiculous|6 years ago

I just see ansolutely no reason why I would use microsoft edge

ravenstine|6 years ago

Edge in its current form is being replaced by a version based on Chromium. I can see why people would want to use that when it becomes default since it would have the advantages of using Chrome but without the extra download.

Beta downloads: https://www.microsoftedgeinsider.com/en-us/download

yardie|6 years ago

Until Firefox and Chrome can take group policies Edge will have an edge in centrally managed office deployments.

I get the best of both worlds. Access to the dev extensions in the Chrome Store as well as Windows pass-through authentication.

vharuck|6 years ago

At my job, the options are Edge or Explorer. I'll admit, neither option leaves me happy.

sys_64738|6 years ago

It'll on the default install of Windows 10 once 1.0 is formally released. When people realize it's Microsoft Chrome then they'll ditch Google's version of Chrome. It's actually a pretty smart move by MS as they'll quickly become the dominant browser again.

mrtksn|6 years ago

It's an endless joy for me when Microsoft fails to get traction with their new shiny browser and changes something as a fresh start.

It's a decent browser but never again IE. Keep rebranding the browser downloading tool, Microsoft.

That said, these days I am annoyed by "This browser is not supported, use Chrome" messages. Maybe the the history does not repeat but rhymes after all.

Browsers should be made by non-profits like mozilla, in my opinion.

pavlov|6 years ago

The new Microsoft Edge is Chromium, so at least you won’t be getting those messages.