top | item 21665658

(no title)

dilutedh2o | 6 years ago

Git is a Blockchain? Did I miss a meeting?

discuss

order

api|6 years ago

Sort of. It's a similar cryptographic hash chain type structure. I believe it's a DAG.

Block chain skepticism has gotten as silly as block chain hype. A block chain is a perfectly valid and sometimes useful structure with some very interesting properties, but it won't cure cancer and make a unicorn fly out of every nose.

spookthesunset|6 years ago

> Block chain skepticism has gotten as silly as block chain hype.

Naw. Technologies that are ecological disasters whose only purpose in the last 10+ years is to serve as a platform for fraud and enrichment of early adopters.... they deserve heaps of criticism.

ownagefool|6 years ago

> Block chain skepticism has gotten as silly as block chain hype.

Is it though?

My admittedly simple understanding is that blockchain is a distributed ledger that suffers from consensus based attacks; as in it's pretty much useless unless the cluster is massive and shared between lots of parties that couldn't really out-compute each other.

Thus the criticisms aren't really "this can never work" but simply, this is usually a waste of compute power and energy compared to a non-distributed version, especially when it's one of these singular company examples.

Would be interested in hearing what's the use cases are.

zitterbewegung|6 years ago

A VCS is a database. A blockchain is a database .

If you use git as intended having a single source of truth (a branch that represents master / deployment) and allows others to submit patches that are then approved to master the data model is very similar to a blockchain.

dilutedh2o|6 years ago

No doubt, but there's no consensus algo like PoW right?