This seems like it would be a bit of a faff. With physical business cards, exchanging them is as simple as moving a card from your pocket into the hand of the person you are giving it to. You can even collect a whole bunch at once and arrange them in front of you to remember everybody’s name at the meeting table. Who really struggles to keep track of physical cards? Insert into holder in alphabetical order when you get back. O(n)
With this there would be at least a couple buttons to mash on the phone, something will almost certainly go wrong with it in the middle of the Big Sales Meeting (sods law), you have to fiddle with your phone instead of looking your new contact in the eye etc etc.
If you are the sort of person that enjoys meticulously tagging mp3 files and has to add every single person they meet to FaceTweetMyspaceLinkedBook then maybe this seems great, but to me this is a solution to a nonexistent problem, that just makes life more difficult.
You go to a meeting, you get 8 business cards, you have to add notes in the lobby or parking lot so that you know who the decision maker was, who the person was that was driving the initiative, and, the person that pays the bills. Identifying the people that you need to contact while it is fresh in your mind is important. Cards are usually traded at the end of a meeting, but, I've always made it a point to swap cards as early in the meeting as possible so I could take notes. Am I going to take notes on my phone? Probably not. That said, people need to quit using glossy two sided cards. I do have a legal pad, but, it is much easier for me to write a quick note on a card because I don't have to worry about two people having the same initials and did I write down the wrong piece of info, etc.
Would transferring those cards be any easier via phone? probably not. I can write quicker than I can open a card, select the person I'm talking with and enter the notes. Having a quick way to pull up the 3-8 cards I just received to type notes, added bonus. Having a way to add a voice memo that can later be transcribed or translated, additional bonus. Able to integrate with my contact management software, extra bonus as well.
That is half the problem, and, in particular, one that Bump, Google Goggles, this product and many others don't appear to handle well. When I go into a meeting, I have to remember who I promised what, who I need to follow up with and when. So far, dead-tree cards fit this purpose better.
Scenario two, I'm at a bar/restaurant or some gathering, perhaps even http://ftlhackandtell.eventbrite.com/ this weekend. I know the community there is likely to be technical, they are probably going to be on top of things, but, if I am there making contacts, there's one thing I need and that is a simple, seamless way of getting that data. I've got to carry Bump, Google Goggles, mynameise, and whatever other possible method I can to make sure I can swap info without having to swap a card. Email addresses are difficult to transcribe in loud settings, certain letters can be confused, people have cutesy names that miss a vowel so that it has to be spelled out letter by letter, etc.
"No, that's mgacontrl.ly yeah, megacontrol without the e and o, well, the first o in control, but not the second o, and .ly, but an l before the ., well, our sales staff liked the name"
Then, you have the conventions. In this case, business cards reign supreme. If I'm at a booth, I'm going to walk away with 200-500 business cards. People will hand me cards just to not hear a sales pitch and to get whatever promo goodies are being handed out. It isn't worth my time to get those cards electronically because 50% or more won't be interested and will give enough cues when I call back that they get moved aside. Of the interested ones, then I'll get those input into the system.
While each of these companies appear to be solving a problem, they really need to talk with the people that have the problem they're solving.
I was talking with a client this morning about the very issue. Three-four month android user, stack of 550 cards gathered over the last month. You know she deals with cards?
Lay them all face down on the photocopier, photocopy 10-13 cards at a time, puts them in a file folder to key into her contact management software on the plane to the next convention. She's very technically savvy, but, there are a host of reasons solutions don't work. Even the conventions have moved away from the barcode reader that reads the id badge and then hands you a list of each person you scanned at the end of the show.
I did tell her about Google Goggles for scanning the cards and she's going to try it on the next stack, but, out of 86 cards I scanned, 3 had errors - those three used serif fonts for the phone numbers. While it is nice for archival purposes, I can't depend on using google goggles at a function (unless it has a way for me to save a copy of the picture somewhere that I haven't seen).
Created card, added logo, meant to add it as the picture, no way to remove the logo, won't allow me to upload a picture of the same name? Actually, won't let me upload at all, Chrome/Mac 10.6.6
Autofill tries to fill in the street number with the City, and the address line gets my street with the number. I'm not sure why you're separating the two fields. You don't ask for my state. The address appears to be incorrect, as I'm in the USA, our street number comes first, so, I'll assume you're not in the USA?
When I try to add my linkedin profile, it says 'Could not add service'. Wasn't obvious that I needed to enter the full url when twitter accepted just my username.
As you get further down and click about.me, the dialog box requires me to scroll up for input, then back down. I couldn't see a way to add my self-hosted blog.
After saving the card on step 2, I am able to upload my photo and deactivate the logo.
I'll give it a try this weekend, however, on android, it is based on email which means I have to hope that the email gets delivered. Does the IPhone app transfer it locally? or still go through your server?
It looks good, pretty easy to navigate. I hope it works out well for you.
Saying that an area the 120% size of Central Park is deforested yearly to create business cards doesn't at all follow from what they claim. There may well be 24,000 trees in NYC's Central Park, but the last time I was there it was far from covered in trees. 30,000 could grow in a far smaller space.
That kind of reasoning doesn't inspire confidence!
I could see something with NFC being much more productive than this. Actually have a plastic card, and just scan that sucker to each other's phones. This is an interesting idea but still doesn't really get rid of the paper usage because people like to have something physical.
[+] [-] alex77|15 years ago|reply
With this there would be at least a couple buttons to mash on the phone, something will almost certainly go wrong with it in the middle of the Big Sales Meeting (sods law), you have to fiddle with your phone instead of looking your new contact in the eye etc etc.
If you are the sort of person that enjoys meticulously tagging mp3 files and has to add every single person they meet to FaceTweetMyspaceLinkedBook then maybe this seems great, but to me this is a solution to a nonexistent problem, that just makes life more difficult.
[+] [-] renn|15 years ago|reply
[+] [-] cd34|15 years ago|reply
You go to a meeting, you get 8 business cards, you have to add notes in the lobby or parking lot so that you know who the decision maker was, who the person was that was driving the initiative, and, the person that pays the bills. Identifying the people that you need to contact while it is fresh in your mind is important. Cards are usually traded at the end of a meeting, but, I've always made it a point to swap cards as early in the meeting as possible so I could take notes. Am I going to take notes on my phone? Probably not. That said, people need to quit using glossy two sided cards. I do have a legal pad, but, it is much easier for me to write a quick note on a card because I don't have to worry about two people having the same initials and did I write down the wrong piece of info, etc.
Would transferring those cards be any easier via phone? probably not. I can write quicker than I can open a card, select the person I'm talking with and enter the notes. Having a quick way to pull up the 3-8 cards I just received to type notes, added bonus. Having a way to add a voice memo that can later be transcribed or translated, additional bonus. Able to integrate with my contact management software, extra bonus as well.
That is half the problem, and, in particular, one that Bump, Google Goggles, this product and many others don't appear to handle well. When I go into a meeting, I have to remember who I promised what, who I need to follow up with and when. So far, dead-tree cards fit this purpose better.
Scenario two, I'm at a bar/restaurant or some gathering, perhaps even http://ftlhackandtell.eventbrite.com/ this weekend. I know the community there is likely to be technical, they are probably going to be on top of things, but, if I am there making contacts, there's one thing I need and that is a simple, seamless way of getting that data. I've got to carry Bump, Google Goggles, mynameise, and whatever other possible method I can to make sure I can swap info without having to swap a card. Email addresses are difficult to transcribe in loud settings, certain letters can be confused, people have cutesy names that miss a vowel so that it has to be spelled out letter by letter, etc.
"No, that's mgacontrl.ly yeah, megacontrol without the e and o, well, the first o in control, but not the second o, and .ly, but an l before the ., well, our sales staff liked the name"
Then, you have the conventions. In this case, business cards reign supreme. If I'm at a booth, I'm going to walk away with 200-500 business cards. People will hand me cards just to not hear a sales pitch and to get whatever promo goodies are being handed out. It isn't worth my time to get those cards electronically because 50% or more won't be interested and will give enough cues when I call back that they get moved aside. Of the interested ones, then I'll get those input into the system.
While each of these companies appear to be solving a problem, they really need to talk with the people that have the problem they're solving.
I was talking with a client this morning about the very issue. Three-four month android user, stack of 550 cards gathered over the last month. You know she deals with cards?
Lay them all face down on the photocopier, photocopy 10-13 cards at a time, puts them in a file folder to key into her contact management software on the plane to the next convention. She's very technically savvy, but, there are a host of reasons solutions don't work. Even the conventions have moved away from the barcode reader that reads the id badge and then hands you a list of each person you scanned at the end of the show.
I did tell her about Google Goggles for scanning the cards and she's going to try it on the next stack, but, out of 86 cards I scanned, 3 had errors - those three used serif fonts for the phone numbers. While it is nice for archival purposes, I can't depend on using google goggles at a function (unless it has a way for me to save a copy of the picture somewhere that I haven't seen).
I miss being in sales. :)
[+] [-] cd34|15 years ago|reply
Created card, added logo, meant to add it as the picture, no way to remove the logo, won't allow me to upload a picture of the same name? Actually, won't let me upload at all, Chrome/Mac 10.6.6
Autofill tries to fill in the street number with the City, and the address line gets my street with the number. I'm not sure why you're separating the two fields. You don't ask for my state. The address appears to be incorrect, as I'm in the USA, our street number comes first, so, I'll assume you're not in the USA?
When I try to add my linkedin profile, it says 'Could not add service'. Wasn't obvious that I needed to enter the full url when twitter accepted just my username.
As you get further down and click about.me, the dialog box requires me to scroll up for input, then back down. I couldn't see a way to add my self-hosted blog.
After saving the card on step 2, I am able to upload my photo and deactivate the logo.
I'll give it a try this weekend, however, on android, it is based on email which means I have to hope that the email gets delivered. Does the IPhone app transfer it locally? or still go through your server?
It looks good, pretty easy to navigate. I hope it works out well for you.
[+] [-] OliverM|15 years ago|reply
That kind of reasoning doesn't inspire confidence!
[+] [-] renn|15 years ago|reply
[+] [-] Alucarddrol|15 years ago|reply
[+] [-] renn|15 years ago|reply
And something physical? Like cassettes? CDs? Newspapers?
[+] [-] sgt|15 years ago|reply
Just be careful who you ask.
[+] [-] unwind|15 years ago|reply
[+] [-] renn|15 years ago|reply
[+] [-] user24|15 years ago|reply
[+] [-] renn|15 years ago|reply