top | item 21898401

(no title)

sgtcodfish | 6 years ago

Do you have an example of a situation where a problem in systemd required you to patch the source and recompile, or are you just making a general statement?

Specifically a problem that couldn't be fixed by changing systemd unit files?

(I don't mean for this to sound in bad faith; I'm genuinely curious as a user of systemd)

discuss

order

johnr2|6 years ago

> Do you have an example of a situation where a problem in systemd required you to patch the source and recompile, or are you just making a general statement?

General statement.

PlutoIsAPlanet|6 years ago

You could use that argument and say do you need to look at all the code for the dozen shell programs you're calling in that init file to diagnose problems.

egberts1|6 years ago

Yes, I do have a problem with systemd dhclient module.

It doesn’t work with Juniper routers that many large ISP providers use.

So I resort to ISC DHCP and its flexible DHCP OPTIONS.

majewsky|6 years ago

That issue is besides the point:

1. It's not relating to the service manager part of systemd. It sounds like a problem with systemd-networkd which is a component that is entirely optional and easily replaced even on a systemd-based system (as you admit yourself).

2. The original question was about bugs in systemd that require inspecting C code where the equivalent bug on a non-systemd system could be diagnosed by inspecting shell scripts. ISC DHCP is not written in shell script.

vbernat|6 years ago

So, you didn't need to recompile or debug anything. Just switch to another DHCP client.

johnny22|6 years ago

which distro uses the systemd dhcp client by default? Even Fedora doesn't do that.