[rwem]

Why do Americans [anything]? Because in short they are ignorant.

Americans lack perspective on virtually all topics. They don't read enough, they don't travel enough, their educations are overwhelmingly technical and occupational at the expense of philosophy and ethics, and their domestic brainwashing apparatus has left them collectively unable to think.

Transportation is just like any other topic American's are unqualified to comment upon, like healthcare. They've been indoctrinated by propaganda campaigns to believe and repeat a series of false statements: their cities are too spread out (they aren't); their cities are exceptionally far apart (they aren't); their weather is somehow unprecedented (it isn't); you can't take groceries/children/lumber home on the bike/bus/tram/train (you obviously can).

So the answer to the headline's question is the obvious one, the one with the most hard evidence and the one with the broadest explanatory powers. The reason Americans believe these things is because of ignorance.

[dang]

Nationalistic flamewar is not ok on HN. You can't post like this here, regardless of which nation you have a problem with. It poisons the commons and provokes much worse from others.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[imgabe]

Europeans plundered and enslaved the world for centuries and now act incredulous that anyone does not have the wealth at their disposal to dole out to their unproductive citizens.

[dang]

Please do not take HN threads further into nationalistic flamewar, regardless of how flamebaity some other comment is.

We need fire prevention in depth here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

[tidenly]

Are you seriously implying the reason America doesn't have public transport or the other public amenities Europe does is because they don't have the money?