top | item 22404082

(no title)

meagain3 | 6 years ago

So just anybody can call themselves engineer?, don't you realize this is a disservice to the actual engineers?

discuss

order

ghaff|6 years ago

Yes. You may not like it. I may not even like it but everyone from people who drive trains to technicians in lots of areas use the title.

Furthermore, tons of experienced working engineers outside of software don't have PEs. They're just not needed in a lot of contexts.

Edit: I'm referring mostly to the US. Licensing bodies in some places (perhaps including some US states) may say that only licensed engineers can be called/are engineers although the degree to which such strictures are followed will almost certainly vary. (I was told this was the case in Texas but there's no shortage of people in Texas who call themselves engineers but aren't PEs.)

chrisseaton|6 years ago

Who gets to decide what makes you an ‘actual’ engineer?

meagain3|6 years ago

Your engineering state association decides. Same as the medical associations, bar associations for lawyers, etc.

meagain3|6 years ago

Addendum: can someone tell me what's wrong with using software developer as a description of what we do?, why do we need to borrow other professions titles?, it's because we want more respect?

inetknght|6 years ago

I would guess that's the short version of it. I would surmise that 'engineer' basically means to do a hell of a lot more rigorous logic testing of the software and hardware products and would therefore also get paid more. Then comes along these fancy little startups who want to hire away that talent but don't fully understand that the word 'engineer' is a protected word in but do know the context basically suggests more responsibility. So then they make leading roles 'engineers' and supporting roles 'developers'. Then it snowballs from there because software isn't _nearly_ as rigorous as a civil engineer or mechanical engineer where the word means that you're legally responsible for the lives at stake.

I honestly think that software "engineers" should be legally liable for the lives at stake though.

deadcat|6 years ago

I've always referred to myself as a Developer, as my degree is Info Tech, not Engineering.

I'm not an accredited engineer, so I feel I have no right to the title.

It really annoys me that some manages at work call themselves Release Train Engineers.