top | item 22530958

(no title)

batterseapower | 6 years ago

If you like the idea of this library you'll probably like the book "How to Measure Anything" by Douglas Hubbard (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/20933591-how-to-measure-...). It's all about how to get sensible confidence intervals for things that are often considered unmeasurable such as the value of IT security. The book mostly uses Excel to do this modelling, but it looks like riskquant would be an excellent alternative on that approach, that for the more technically minded practitioner.

discuss

order

jacques_chester|6 years ago

The relevant book for this is Measuring and Managing Information Risk: A FAIR Approach by Freund and Jones[0].

Both books are worth reading; Hubbard's influence on FAIR is noticeable and positive. FAIR has the advantage that it comes with a fairly built-out ontology for assembling data or estimates. The OP touches on the top level (Loss Event Magnitude and Loss Event Frequency), but the ontology goes quite deep and can be used at multiple levels of detail.

The calculations are not difficult, I've implemented them twice in proofs-of-concept, including one that produces pretty charts.

The difficult part, to be honest, is that developing good estimates is difficult and frequently uncomfortable and the gains are not easily internalised.

Additionally, serious tool support is lacking in the places where it would make a difference -- issue trackers, for example.

[0] https://www.amazon.com/Measuring-Managing-Information-Risk-A...

edit -- Another good book in this area is Waltzing with Bears by DeMarco & Lister. A short, funny, insightful read, as you'd expect from the authors of PeopleWare: https://www.amazon.com/Waltzing-Bears-Managing-Software-Proj...

lifeisstillgood|6 years ago

I regularly put a risk / loss / impact assessment into my issue tracker tickets - it's not the tool support is not there, it's that

a) everyone else needs to do this across the board

b) it's still just a guess - normalising my guess and you're guess is hard

thanatropism|6 years ago

I have that book. Basically I’m the last in a giveaway chain and can’t honestly recommend it enough that someone should lug it home. Next time I move it’s going on the trash.

It’s really not very good, even for executives who shouldn’t care for technicalities. The best thing are the calibration exercises. But my advice is, skip this one.

qznc|6 years ago

Can you elaborate?

I'm half-way through it. I know most of the general stuff already but my knowledge is from lots of sources I mostly forgot. This books seems to be a good collection for this topic. At least, I don't know any substitute.

mindcrime|6 years ago

It’s really not very good

Compared to what?

But my advice is, skip this one.

And read what instead?

Not trying to start an argument here, I'm genuinely curious, as I consider How To Measure Anything to be one of the best books I've ever read (and I read a lot of books), and I recommend it highly to, well, pretty much everybody. If you feel that there's a better resource out there that relates to these topics, I'd be curious to know about it.