[fhenneke]

The tokens are engineered to protect the private key material stored inside them very well, so you can be quite certain that nobody will ever be able to log in without physical access to the key (to touch/press the button).

However, the SSH protocol differs quite substantially from the FIDO2/WebAuthn spec in how it uses the PIN set on the token. Depending on how the SSH server is configured and which defaults your security token's manufacturer chose, it may be the case that the PIN is not needed to log in (assuming physical access to the token).

I hope that all of this will be clarified in the OpenSSH documentation at some point as it is quite vague about security guarantees at the moment. It's probably best to use the non-resident version of the new key type together with a passphrase on the key file for now, or rely on the PIV applet instead.

[StavrosK]

Oh huh, that's unfortunate. I was under the impression that the Yubikey would not sign anything without a PIN, period, and that it wipes its contents after three (ten?) wrong attempts. This greatly reduces the security of the token, and it's a shame since we were so close to perfect...