top | item 23246529

(no title)

ajphdiv | 5 years ago

Not illegal. Sites like shodan.io would have an issue if it was.

discuss

order

wrkronmiller|5 years ago

IANAL but this type of websocket port scan seems inherently different from what Shodan does.

Shodan is outside your network's firewall, therefore only able to access services you've exposed to the wider web.

If I understand the article, the websocket scan eBay is doing is trying to connect to local listeners on your laptop, behind your network's firewall and possibly even behind your laptop's firewall.

gnu8|5 years ago

This is such an obvious consequence of web sockets that I wonder how anyone could have entertained the idea long enough to sober up and write the code. This is worse than letting a web page script have access to the clipboard, record mouse movements, and similar information leaks, because instead of just stealing information, now a web page can actively compromise any host on your network.

bzb3|5 years ago

That's a fallacious argument. The fact that someone is doing something doesn't mean it's automatically legal.

TechBro8615|5 years ago

IANAL, but more likely it depends on intent and context. So shodan.io is okay because it’s not explicitly malicious, and they have clear paths to contact them if you suspect abuse. Whereas, if you’re suspected of hacking a website, the fact that you port scanned it a week prior to password spraying it might serve as evidence against you. That is, it seems unlikely anyone would be prosecuted for port scanning alone, but it could be an act that demonstrates intent of a later action.

One time, I port scanned my public IP (of my ISP) from an EC2 box, and I got an email from EC2 saying they received an abuse complaint from the ISP for port scanning activity.

ajphdiv|5 years ago

The more pointed argument would be there is no federal law prohibiting port scans.