top | item 23967827

(no title)

kingkilr | 5 years ago

One of the folks behind the bounty here. Happy to answer questions.

discuss

order

stevekemp|5 years ago

I can think of ten security-critical applications/services off the top of my head which are will never accept patches/changes to rewrite some/all of them in memory-safe languages.

I appreciate the goal of using languages better suited to memory-safety, but when I look at CVE lists including the same recurring projects I can't help thinking that the bounties here are not going to help.

(For example imagemagick/graphicmagic, the linux kernel, even wordpress/jenkins plugins, and similar things are regular candidates for security issues - and they're not going to get rewritten/modified-in-place to use rust/golang any time soon.)

philipkglass|5 years ago

WordPress is written in PHP and Jenkins is written in Java. These are already memory-safe languages. Security problems in their plugins rarely if ever derive from memory safety issues.

kingkilr|5 years ago

The kernel maintainers have actively expressed interest in having upstream support for writing kernel modules in Rust!