top | item 24289454

(no title)

xbeta | 5 years ago

I did the same with two of my kids, and we have more than two languages to consider. We want something simple to write, spell, and pronounce in all 2 languages + dialects: Cantonese, Mandarin, English.

It is super challenging. And some of my relatives are super into 八字 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pillars_of_Destiny) that also need to make sure the characters written in Chinese can align with that too.

discuss

order

nathanhammond|5 years ago

Is this published anywhere? Constraints I'm trying to solve for:

- Reasonable English corollary. (Doesn't have to be 1:1.)

- English-pronounceable Cantonese romanization.

- English-pronounceable Mandarin romanization.

- Doesn't diverge too much between the three.

- Characters that are identical in Traditional and Simplified.

- Pleasing to the relatives.

xbeta|5 years ago

Yep, absolutely. These constraints probably yield nothing in return. We have take compromise in some of these.