top | item 24712181

(no title)

throwaway373438 | 5 years ago

And this is why Google had to copy the interface -- otherwise their runtime would not operate with other existing products. As you can see given your example, the analogy is a perfect fit.

Your argument that the copying is once-removed is unfortunately irrelevant to copyright law.

discuss

order

mehrdadn|5 years ago

You're saying a car that's 1 inch narrower somehow wouldn't fit the same roads?

throwaway373438|5 years ago

What does "1 inch narrower" mean to you, in the context of this analogy? Are you suggesting the interfaces have different names? Different sized arguments?

None of those things would work.

Besides, creating minor differences do not solve this problem as they would still be derivative works.