top | item 25521473

(no title)

aleem | 5 years ago

Point this thing at the stock market and see how that game plays out.

discuss

order

hnracer|5 years ago

Many very smart people have tried and failed. State of the art remains very basic supervised models with hand engineered features. In the markets, data is permanently scarce, so these methods don't work well. In the RL problems that DeepMind is solving, data is literally unlimited, and that's the problem space that these methods have been designed for.

patagurbon|5 years ago

It's not so clear to me how you would train a reinforcement learning agent for the stock market. You have historic data for prices etc. But that's more of a supervised learning thing. You could set it loose on one of those realtime market simulators, but the agents actions wouldn't have any impact on the simulation right?

hnracer|5 years ago

There's two problems in markets, price prediction and execution (ie what to do with your prediction). The former is a supervised learning problem but the latter is an action space problem ie an RL problem. Although nobody in industry has gotten any RL methods too work, they overfit to the incredibly small data sets.