[ordinaryperson]

Sometimes yes, sometimes no.

Counter-example: Jenkins. It does what you ask of it, its base install is "naked" and only contains the minimum functionality in the core.

Everything then becomes a plugin. Git. GitHub. Branch for multi-branch pipelines. Credentials management. And on and on and on.

Now you have stay on top of maintaining the plugins in addition to the core. Also, many plugins require other plugins so just to do some basic stuff like set up a multi-branch pipeline from a GitHub repo you're suddenly staring down the barrel of dozens and dozens of bespoke plugins with varying levels of quality and support.

A monolithic application like curl is a dream to me by comparison. Everything is tested in every release. Sub-components are kept up to date by the maintainer. No plugins fighting each other's plugins.

From afar it's easy to see the praise simplicity and modularization but honestly monoliths can be undervalued too.

[dkarl]

I can definitely see your point, having experienced the same thing with plugins for SBT, the Scala build tool. I didn't really consider the case of a small core with a multitude of plugins as a twist on the small, simple tool. I think you're right that a plugin architecture lets a thousand flowers bloom, but you don't get long-term stability, because people move on to other tools and stop maintaining the plugins they wrote.

For example, VSCode plugins are great because VSCode is thriving, and Emacs packages are a crapshoot because many of the programmers who wrote them have moved on. Eventually VSCode plugins will be like Emacs packages.

[seanp2k2]

Also: node. Everything is a module, and every module requires a hundred more. Projects with thousands of dependencies become common. No one understands what is actually “under the hood” and hardly anyone cares. “It just works” most of the time. Good enough.

Sad.

[htrp]

well written monoliths are the dream.....

curl is a utility, like power.

you don't worry about electricity not being able to power your TV because it was designed for light bulbs, it just works.