top | item 27550825

(no title)

halbritt | 4 years ago

How is a DEI policy "left" or "right"?

discuss

order

greenail|4 years ago

I think one way to measure how far left or right by looking at how far they take "Equity". If equity is an anti-racist version of "racial equity" then it demands "anti-racist" discrimination. To quote Kendi

"The only remedy to racist discrimination is anti-racist discrimination. The only remedy to past discrimination is present discrimination. The only remedy to present discrimination is future discrimination."

happyopossum|4 years ago

It doesn’t have to be, but it has been made “left” in many companies. Start with seminars and zoom calls with progressive politicians as guests, donate company $$ to organizations that support civil rights while espousing Marxist beliefs, enable volunteer time to support certain types of politicians, etc.

And that’s all aside from the instances of forcing CRT training on the workforce - plenty of controversy there as well.

This stuff happens more than you’d think.

greenail|4 years ago

I have seen all your examples in a top tech firm. In that same firm any public questioning was quickly shouted down in a way that made it clear that your were putting your career at risk by asking why the company was promoting left leaning politics through DEI.

astrange|4 years ago

"Critical race theory" and "Marxism" are literally two different theories that oppose each other.

Clewza313|4 years ago

The more extreme ideologies of DEI like critical race theory are closely associated with (in American terms) "the liberal left".

dragonwriter|4 years ago

> The more extreme ideologies of DEI like critical race theory are closely associated with (in American terms) "the liberal left".

“Critical race theory” isn’t either extreme or an ideology, its a fairly mainstream historiographic approach (it was a novel, but not particularly extreme, idea in its field nearly half a century ago, but now its not even that) that the American Right has recently adopted public opposition to (especially, oddly enough, in places it isn’t being promoted) as a tribal identity symbol (alongside election conspiracy theories and defiance of COVID precautions.)

EDIT: It’s particularly odd to call “critical race theory” as an “extreme ideology of DEI” since DEI existing at all as a thing is based on a mainstream understanding of reality developed through critical race theory.