top | item 27885274

(no title)

rcoumet | 4 years ago

> Vasya has 2 sisters more than he has brothers. How many daughters more than sons do Vasya’s parents have?

In a world of gender and pronouns fluidity, does this even have an answer ?

discuss

order

dang|4 years ago

"Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

jMyles|4 years ago

Although I adore this guideline, I do want to step in to defend this comment.

I think that many parents are trying to teach kids in this age range to take a wider view of the possibilities of family shapes and gender identities, and a question of this wording does indeed confound that.

jMyles|4 years ago

It is also nuclear-presumptive: it presumes that Vasya's parents have only daughters and sons with each other.

culebron21|4 years ago

Curiously, Vasya (short for Vasiliy) can be a short form of girl's name Vasilisa (though it's rare).

I can't recall any mention of divorce apart from school Literature course when I was in school in the 90s (most of material was inherited from the Soviet times).

Knowing how Soviet editorial policies worked, I'm assured the editors considered mentioning divorces or non-married parents as seeding wrong attitudes and thus inappropriate for kids.