top | item 29008406

(no title)

andydb | 4 years ago

Our product roadmap will be heavily influenced by customer asks. So if there are things about CockroachDB Serverless that prevent you from using it (like requiring ingress through a public IP), we definitely want to hear about it.

Regarding a cluster limit, we currently allow up to 5 clusters per customer account. I'd like to hear what kind of use-cases you have in mind for having a lot more clusters. One I've thought about is CI runs, where you'd want dozens or hundreds of temporary clusters running at once, in order to run your testing in parallel.

discuss

order

WatchDog|4 years ago

I guess two main use-cases come to mind, providing isolated multi-tenant saas services, also easily creating test/dev environments.

In a similar vein to how you have made cockroach multi-tenant, not too long ago I worked on building a multi-tenant sass version of a business intelligence app. The app uses a relational DB, initially we used separate schemas on the same db cluster, but we had problems with noisy neighbors, as well as concerns about it's security.

We later opted to run dedicated database clusters for each tenant, however it greatly increases the marginal cost, and makes it difficult to provide a free tier of service, which is a valuable way to gain new customers.

andydb|4 years ago

I think you're right on target with the multi-tenant SAAS services. They often suffer from the "long-tail" problem, where the tiny customers without much usage cost too much to host. And of course, that's one of the big problems the CockroachDB Serverless architecture solves.

There's no technical reason why CockroachDB Serverless couldn't support that scenario - it's more of a product/business/sales question. I think we'd be very open to talking with companies that have that kind of problem to solve.

ranguna|4 years ago

The main thing that's keeping me from moving to cockroachDB is that it doesn't support triggers. Once triggers are supported, I'll jump out of aws in a millisecond.