[sleevi]

It’s actually a huge issue - look at how eliminating a key difficulty in obtaining certificates massively increased HTTPS adoption (via LetsEncrypt and others)

Similarly, automation affects how easy or hard it is to replace a CA, for example, if moving to distrust a CA. If you rely on QWAC attributes, you can only use QWAC CAs, and changing CAs becomes significantly more complex.

The audit issue is definitely an issue: the audits used are fundamentally different than what browsers try to achieve, and so having to adopt the lower standard definitely impacts user security. However, my point was that in addition to those concerns, the technical design itself results in less robust and less agile systems, and that makes things less secure.