top | item 29912886

(no title)

justicezyx | 4 years ago

Words are thoughts. Thoughts are mental processes. Be careful with treating similarity in appearance with equivalence in substance.

> social harmony and the rule of law

The association between the story and social harmony seems plausible, but actually superficial.

Social harmony would be that people involuntarily work together without an authority, and reached mutual agreement on their dispute. To me, it is a sign of social conflicts that dark web actors need arbitration.

Although that by itself matches our impression that dark web actors are lawless individuals should be punished. More ironically, the story actually shows that they are not lawless in the absolute sense. They just breakd the laws majority of the society abides by (or the majority actually do not even realize exits).

> rule of law

You know, rule of law is more of a political term nowadays. It refers to a western style of political organization framework centered on written laws and a voting process to revising them, and many other subtle details.

Is arbitration on darkweb an example of rule by law?

I tend to say no. Arbiter is necessary in all steps, and they seem are not codifying their "laws" for dealing with the future occrance of similar litigation at all.

discuss

order

papito|4 years ago

Well, obviously, this is almost a metaphor, as it's a stretch to literally apply the term Rule of Law to something as sketchy as the dark web. Also, note that I did not use something like "Law and Order", as that can have a pretty unpleasant meaning.