top | item 30146461

(no title)

flebron | 4 years ago

Consider a disconnected domain (say, union of a few open balls in R^n), and f being constant in each connected component, but having different values in each ball. The differential is indeed everywhere 0 in the entire domain.

discuss

order

dataflow|4 years ago

D'oh, I missed the possibility of an open domain. Thanks!

sannee|4 years ago

And, even better, the dimension of the kernel of d just counts how many connected components the domain has.

There is a similar thing in graph theory, where the kernel of the incidence matrix counts how many connected components a graph has.

bmitc|4 years ago

Yea, the statement is missing "locally constant". It's a poor example given the assumptions are not clearly stated.

pfortuny|4 years ago

Oh, these kind of problems happen time and again in real-life maths: you use a lemma until someone points out that you are assuming something which may not take place (like connectedness of the domain, here).