top | item 30541307

(no title)

jonenst | 4 years ago

This website is overloaded with adds. It almost feels like a scam. Based on the fact that almost all other comments are not talking about it, I guess at least one of the following hypotheses is true (if not all of them): - most people here use an efficient addblocker - The website changed since its first appearance on the first page (maximize revenue?) - some comments are sponsored - on mobile it feels overwhelming but on desktops it's more bearable

discuss

order

toyg|4 years ago

> - most people here use an efficient addblocker

Yup. I was like, "this is a very oldschool site, super-essential, bare styling..." I guess all that whitespace is covered in ads for you, lol.

wsinks|4 years ago

ha! I don't use an adblocker, and when I first loaded this page, it looked great! and then I quickly quit out and came to the comments instead of using it. And then I saw this, and went back...

Oh. I just wasn't on the page long enough to see just how many ads were loaded, wow!!

Nashooo|4 years ago

It also tried to autocomplete CC data.. Feels like a scam.

nickcw|4 years ago

It did that for me too. I can't see why though when looking at the HTML.

    <form name="Cerca" method="get" action="index.php">
    <input type="text" name="sur" size="8">
    <input type="submit" name="s" value="Search">
    </form>
Maybe it is a bug in Chrome.

weatherlight|4 years ago

same tried to autocomplete CC data as well. (was using chrome)

mlatu|4 years ago

> overloaded

?

got curious enough to turn off my adblocker: i was presented with TWO ads on desktop

i think you overloaded the term overloaded.

though they are huge on mobile.. and appear to be subleased or something. also there appears to be another ad element below the "(C)" line on mobile which is missing on desktop

mynameisvlad|4 years ago

There also seems to be a modal ad on hover out. Hadn't seen that used before for ads.

freeflight|4 years ago

This made me curious, so I reloaded the site without uBlock origin, and for the most part looks the same; There is one ad at the top, one at the bottom, and a cookie info style ad banner scrolling with the page, 3 ads in total.

That's a rather humane amount and the only one that's really intrusive is the one all the way on the top, the scrolling banner can even be minimized to remove it, which leaves a total of 2 ads on the site, at least for me on Chrome.

zdragnar|4 years ago

On android chrome, I'm seeing 9 distinct ads just on the front page. Inner pages (specific countries) don't have quite so many.

xboxnolifes|4 years ago

This is the same for me. I only get the top and bottom banner ads that I was used to seeing 10+ years ago. Still too big, but they don't make the site unusable.

marcodiego|4 years ago

I haven't seen any ad. Thanks adblockers!

rootbear|4 years ago

I gave up as soon as I realized that the form at the top was an ad and not part of the page. What a mess!

stronglikedan|4 years ago

> overloaded with adds

Overloaded? There's two ads per page, and occasionally one when I click a map, and they're not even in the way.

reaperducer|4 years ago

Strangely, I see no ads, and I don't use any ad blockers. Maybe it only shows ads to people in certain regions?

pooper|4 years ago

I flagged this submission and recommend this post be deleted and the submitter penalized.

mynameisvlad|4 years ago

Is there a rule about not posting submissions with ads? If so, most news sites would likely be heavily penalized.

In other words, what rules exactly do you think this post violated, and why should the submitter be penalized? For posting a site with ads?

ChrisRR|4 years ago

Why? Sites need ads to keep running. There's only two fixed ads and one popup

sjmm1989|4 years ago

I've accepted that the internet wants my data and have been using Brave for a few years now. Seems like a fair compromise, and their adblocking is pretty decent, even if I get to put up with their little pop ups now and then for BAT tokens.

I have it set to maximum ad rate, and just ignore them mostly. They are sort of intrusive, but also not really. Depends on what you are doing. I've had them pop up in the middle of working on some word file or excel sheet; but I also get my discord notifications the same way as well...

They don't interrupt gameplay though... usually? Depends on if you have a browser open while playing something in windowed mode I think. At that point you might get one or two popping through due to the browser being open. That sort of thing.

Again, seems like a fair compromise to me. People onboard with BAT get paid one way or the other, and I get to deal with less ads overall. (Seriously, it's a chasm of epic proportions the comparison between before and after.)

Youtube works fine, most websites work fine, and if ever one doesn't want to play nice; you either find something else or just turn off Brave shield temporarily. I've had to do this from time to time with banking for instance, since it was blocking something related to the banks log in process. lol. So yeah, it's not perfect by any means. But it's a far cry better than the others so far in my opinion.

And for those who may want to reply with something about how X browser is worse or better than Brave; that's nice but honestly at this point I don't really care anymore. I have Firefox on standby for those few situations where chromium based browsers just don't want to work, and guess what, that's basically all of them now; Brave included.

So far, this combo has fared me pretty well. If I could get something that does what Brave does even better without the crypto stuff included, I probably would use it instead. But that's probably going to end up being a heavily modified version of Firefox or Chromium somehow; and thus my earlier point about being 'good enough'.

temp0826|4 years ago

There aren't enough tokens in the world to make me accept what you describe about brave. Always surprised when I read HNers actually using it. It just sounds really scummy what they do to me.

klyrs|4 years ago

Quoting your dead comment for educational purposes...

> Just like how none here have a legitimate reason to downvote something that is just my personal preference and opinion based on usage.

Please read the guidelines. Crabbing about downvotes is on there.

> (Seriously people... be better than redditors.)

Please read the guidelines. Calling this reddit is on there.

> P.S. Who ever flagged my comment... grow up. There is no possible way I am breaking any rules right now. Not that I am immediately aware of at least.

Bottom left corner of the page. You're welcome.

failedengineer|4 years ago

That top ad, the one with the "search for names" text boxes that sure looks like you're entering info for your website that actually redirects you to another search website... yeah, that one is particularly pernicious.