"The emigrants are forbidden from taking their money with them, and parliamentarians have already introduced proposals that emigrants be stripped of their citizenship and their property be nationalized."
These laws will not only hit the emigrants of today, but also many people who left Russia long time ago, but might still own an apartment or still have some money in the bank there. I know people who rent out their apartment in Russia or offered it on AirBnB and made a living from it. These are not oligarchs. These are pretty average Russian people. They will suffer badly.
The thesis of the article is that Russians have a long standing fear from the USSR days that the border would one day be closed, and then they couldn't get out of Russia. That fear followed by the recent airspace closures, has led to significant emigration. And this fear has an even earlier trauma of closed borders from the 1917 revolution, which also saw hundreds of thousands emigrate from Russia.
It goes on to make comparisons between the two emigrations, then and now. But also the different perspectives: those who flee and those who stay. Those who stayed following 1917 were very critical of those who fled, the same is happening already today. The author doesn't question whether history will repeat itself, it shows it is. Including for those who leave.
>That they will be welcomed abroad as "Putin’s people," and not at all as those who fought desperately, although unsuccessfully, against him for 20 years.
>Lenin called intellectuals the "shit" of the nation and did everything in his power to make them leave or disappear. Putin has rid himself of this "shit" just as effectively.
Your comment is also for Abiturienten. It would have been a real good comment 20 years ago on some PHP forum, but it doesn't fit to hackernews nowadays.
I wish there would be journalists out there bringing facts first and leave the opinion about the facts for the reader. When reading the first lines it becomes clear to me, that I am reading a opinion based article, not fact based.
I am tired and exhausted of articles like this in the media coverage these times. They don't get my attention. How did this land here on hackernews?
> I wish there would be journalists out there bringing facts first and leave the opinion about the facts for the reader. When reading the first lines it becomes clear to me, that I am reading a opinion based article, not fact based.
It's an op-ed essay. "The media" has always published stuff like this, and newspapers have a section dedicated to it. People are interested in facts, but they're also interested in what other people think and the ideas they have.
The content in a typical newspaper is extremely varied, and rightly so. Did you know they even publish cartoons, and have done so for more than a century?
It’s an essay, not a field report. Persuasive writing. I thought it was interesting, and this isn’t some random letter-to-the-editor. You can read his opinion and form your own rebuttal (I’d love to read it, too!)
[+] [-] amai|4 years ago|reply
These laws will not only hit the emigrants of today, but also many people who left Russia long time ago, but might still own an apartment or still have some money in the bank there. I know people who rent out their apartment in Russia or offered it on AirBnB and made a living from it. These are not oligarchs. These are pretty average Russian people. They will suffer badly.
[+] [-] tromp|4 years ago|reply
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJVYqP6eF2U
I sympathize with anyone trying to escape from such rhetoric.
[+] [-] cmurf|4 years ago|reply
It goes on to make comparisons between the two emigrations, then and now. But also the different perspectives: those who flee and those who stay. Those who stayed following 1917 were very critical of those who fled, the same is happening already today. The author doesn't question whether history will repeat itself, it shows it is. Including for those who leave.
>That they will be welcomed abroad as "Putin’s people," and not at all as those who fought desperately, although unsuccessfully, against him for 20 years.
>Lenin called intellectuals the "shit" of the nation and did everything in his power to make them leave or disappear. Putin has rid himself of this "shit" just as effectively.
[+] [-] amai|4 years ago|reply
It should be obvious that Russians fleeing from their home country nowadays are definitely not "Putin's people" .
[+] [-] throwawaymanbot|4 years ago|reply
[deleted]
[+] [-] mediumsmart|4 years ago|reply
[+] [-] amai|4 years ago|reply
[+] [-] ewokone|4 years ago|reply
I wish there would be journalists out there bringing facts first and leave the opinion about the facts for the reader. When reading the first lines it becomes clear to me, that I am reading a opinion based article, not fact based.
I am tired and exhausted of articles like this in the media coverage these times. They don't get my attention. How did this land here on hackernews?
[+] [-] tablespoon|4 years ago|reply
It's an op-ed essay. "The media" has always published stuff like this, and newspapers have a section dedicated to it. People are interested in facts, but they're also interested in what other people think and the ideas they have.
The content in a typical newspaper is extremely varied, and rightly so. Did you know they even publish cartoons, and have done so for more than a century?
[+] [-] ethagknight|4 years ago|reply
I couldn’t disagree with you more.
[+] [-] vincent_s|4 years ago|reply
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essay
[+] [-] brokensegue|4 years ago|reply
[+] [-] NicoJuicy|4 years ago|reply
Most of them want to relocate outside Russia.
I think it's more than an opinion though.
[+] [-] rosndo|4 years ago|reply
[deleted]
[+] [-] hulitu|4 years ago|reply