top | item 30888579

(no title)

it_does_follow | 3 years ago

discuss

order

divan|3 years ago

Honestly, this is the dumbest and most pseudo-intellectual comment I've ever seen on HN.

Next time russian soldier will be raping your wife or russian bomb destroying your home, please update us on your views on resisting violence.

tluyben2|3 years ago

> It's far better for people to simply be occupied than fight back

You are joking I hope? Have you lived or been born in an occupied territory or perhaps forgot to read some history? You can argue about every single incursion by the US or otherwise, but there are definite ‘simply be occupied’ by internal or external forces where people were slaughtered and no one ever really lived in peace until the regime was disbanded.

Maybe you live somewhere safe and do not have family members to tell you how absurd this is after they actually did live in occupied territory; for instance in the USSR.

gjm11|3 years ago

Is anything in your second paragraph actually true?

That is: does Pinker actually say anything like that, or did you just say he did because it makes him sound stupid and evil?

s5300|3 years ago

All is well until you happen to be part of the group the top decides needs some “ethnic cleansing”

bitcharmer|3 years ago

> resisting violence itself is the primary cause of violence

> better to just lay down an let things happen.

I really hope this is sarcasm or some elaborate intellectual joke. Sitting back and letting it happen as you describe it is exactly what the German population did before the Holocaust.

Also: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance