top | item 31410952

(no title)

Noos | 3 years ago

Why do you even compare the two?

The death penalty is done to a tiny portion of criminals, is subject to very strict procedures and rules, has plenty of time to appeal, and is generally not "murder" by any description necessary. It can be misused of course, and there's plenty of arguments it is unnecessary, but we abort 800k alone per year in the USA and there's significant debate about the humanity of what the procedure is inflicted on. We have killed 1550 people this year for the death penalty.

They are two different things. You might as well say all prolife people should be anti-war and all prochoice people be pro-war for that rationale. I never see why people think this is a gotcha of hypocrisy.

discuss

order

robonerd|3 years ago

> We have killed 1550 people this year for the death penalty.

You're considerably off with that. In America, 6 people have been executed so far in 2022 and 11 people were executed for the whole of 2021.