In my experience, the greatest teachers rarely have the official title "teacher". I learned more from one programmer in 5 months working with him than I did in my entire computer science degree. (And no, I'm not saying professors or degrees are useless, just that I don't think title's and reputation necessarily tell you much about how much a person will teach you.)
And honestly, reading "Uncle Bob's" advice, I find a lot of it is outright bad (here's a good breakdown: https://qntm.org/clean ), or specific to Java's quirks, or has no actual backing other than that Bob think's it's a good idea.
It is great you had a mentor. I met few people I could learn from and books (including Bob’s) were very helpful. He promoted TDD, good names, short functions etc Is he too dogmatic? Are his function too short? Probably yes.
I never treat his proposals as a silver bullet, but a great source of inspiraton. I wish there were more people teaching those things.
overgard|3 years ago
And honestly, reading "Uncle Bob's" advice, I find a lot of it is outright bad (here's a good breakdown: https://qntm.org/clean ), or specific to Java's quirks, or has no actual backing other than that Bob think's it's a good idea.
keyraycheck|3 years ago
I never treat his proposals as a silver bullet, but a great source of inspiraton. I wish there were more people teaching those things.