[isaac21259]

What about irrational numbers? There's no neat way to view multiplication of two irrational numbers as repeated addition. And even if there were a way I don't think it's a useful way to think or teach after the first couple years because it makes obvious things like √2×√2 = 2 seem weird and mysterious.

[hervature]

Others have handled the appropriate construction of irrational numbers. The claim here is not that every student needs to know irrational numbers are a limiting sequence but this is exactly how mathematicians think of it. So it is strange to hear another mathematician claim that repeated addition is somehow lying. At some point, people kind of just accept that it is just something you punch into your calculator and don't even think about it anymore.

Your example is quite bad because sqrt(2)*sqrt(2) = sqrt(2*2) = sqrt(4) = 2. So repeated addition works fine. Let's focus instead on pi*pi. The way calculators do this is precisely as some type of limiting sequence depending on how much precision you want. Because, one cannot "calculate" pi*pi exactly because it is irrational. So, you have 3*3, then 3.1*3.1, then 3.14*3.14, etc. which are all repeated additions with some division (e.g. 314*314/(100*100)). In reality, when multiplying two irrational numbers, we just use enough decimal points for floating point precision and then chop off any potentially erroneous digits after the multiplication.*

[HidyBush]

Irrational numbers are limits of sequences of rational numbers. Multiplying two real numbers is simply taking the limit of a sequence of multiplications between rational numbers that converge to the two real ones.

[isaac21259]

That's a pretty far departure from the original "multiplication is just repeated addition". Regardless, I don't think any student would find it helpful to hear "Multiplying two real numbers is simply taking the limit of a sequence of multiplications between rational numbers that converge to the two real ones". In my country irrational numbers are introduced two or three years before limits so you couldn't teach it in schools effectively either.