top | item 32750073

(no title)

hpkuarg | 3 years ago

Not the OP, but Americans as a whole are very unhealthy (with 42% of the population being obese and over two-thirds being overweight) and culturally have very high expectations of what medicine can do for them, as opposed to making difficult changes to their lifestyle.

A part of the latter is based on the actual superiority of the quality of medical care in this country -- due to the high levels of wealth produced by this (mostly market-oriented) economy and advanced medical technology, doctors can in fact perform miracles here that they cannot elsewhere.

discuss

order

Broken_Hippo|3 years ago

A part of the latter is based on the actual superiority of the quality of medical care in this country...

How is it superior? Sure, some countries fare worse. But folks aren't getting the healthcare they need because of cost, and the results aren't exactly the best in the world. I'm not convinced that "culturally" folks have high expectations either, and sure, you might want to change your lifestyle to lose weight - but at the same time, you might just need medical oversight to do so. Not to mention that a bunch of things medicine helps are not things that lifestyle just fixes.

hpkuarg|3 years ago

Yes, folks are being priced out of healthcare, but the healthcare that is being provided is of superior quality than can be found in other countries -- even first world countries with socialized healthcare. I mean it in that narrow sense, that the service that is being delivered is of higher quality.

It sounds like your point is that wider delivery of healthcare would be superior overall. That's fine, but I contend that the best way to achieve that is by increasing the supply of healthcare providers, instead of applying a price ceiling, which leads to shortages (as seen elsewhere on this thread[0]) and quality deterioration.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32745467