top | item 33923760

(no title)

IfOnlyYouKnew | 3 years ago

“They’ve decided that picking the cotton is better than refusing to do so”.

Edit, because people share a characteristic with heavy metals: the point is that a “choice” made under economic duress is not made freely. Slavery is an extreme example used to make the point more obvious. The threat of violence used to compel people to work the fields is obviously worse than, but not necessarily qualitatively different from, the threat of abject poverty if one refuses to take low-paying insecure jobs.

discuss

order

Wohlf|3 years ago

Food delivery is not even in the same universe as chattel slavery, they're completely incomparable.

pessimizer|3 years ago

You can't just say this, you have to say why. It's going to be a hard case to explain how you can't compare two types of work.

I'm not even sure how you can explain what free market labor is without referring to slavery, or explain what slavery is without referring to free market labor i.e. I don't think it's possible not to compare them and rationally talk about either of them.

melvyn2|3 years ago

Nope, 300 years ago we had slavery and now we have gig work. I think that's the same universe ;)

In all seriousness, refusing to compare two things because you think they're "just too different" is simply acting irrationally. Look at the objectives, pressures, and outputs of each system and you may see more similarities than you'd like.

kodyo|3 years ago

Comments like this are why I don't believe in democracy anymore.