top | item 34736828

(no title)

delaaxe | 3 years ago

A completely unchanging monetary policy is a stupid monetary policy

discuss

order

rahen|3 years ago

Except monetary policies _are_ the problem.

Bitcoin has a simple policy: no one, not even Satoshi, can change the rules.

tempestn|3 years ago

Can you expand on that first line? What is the problem that's inherent in monetary policies?

UncleMeat|3 years ago

But the rules can be dumb. The exponential decay of rewards is, in my opinion, wildly unethical and leads to great harm. It permanently creates a system of haves and have-nots. That a system that cannot be changed is not in any way evidence that the system is good.

We could imagine an alternative system that Satoshi programmed that, once per year, chose 5% of wallets at random and marked those coins as invalid, permanently destroying them. That would be an unchangeable system but it would also be idiotic. Just because there isn't a bureaucrat does not mean that there is no policy.

Phlarp|3 years ago

This is nonsense. The rules can and will be easily changed if/when enough miners agree they should change.