top | item 34808320

(no title)

mikymoothrowa | 3 years ago

[flagged]

discuss

order

01acheru|3 years ago

I'm sorry but I really don't think this is true and almost any source would prove you wrong.

Like this one for example: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index

Almost all countries up in the list are so called "Western", while India is number 46. Most sources would more or less agree with this index.

mikymoothrowa|3 years ago

obviously indices created by the west would rank themselves higher.

India has a much more robust democracy because Indians have several dozen political parties to choose from unlike the US which has only 2 recognised parties.

India has had Prime Ministers from even very small regional parties that formed giant coalitions.

Americans meanwhile are stuck with 2 parties they perpetually hate

rhaway84773|3 years ago

India is not even a hundred year old democracy. It’s way too early to speak about its robustness as a democracy.

Especially considering India has already had a non-Democratic period during emergency, which the previous leadership of the BJP understood the dangers of, since many of them were arrested then, but the current leadership seems keen on basically establishing as the norm.

Unfortunately the hubris and over-confidence you’re displaying is in itself a huge factor in a country losing its democratic nature.

mikymoothrowa|3 years ago

then imagine what the collective hubris and arrogance displayed by the people in this sub-thread would imply about their respective countries’ democratic nature.

shadowfox|3 years ago

> India is much more robust democratically.

Out of curiosity, why do you think that is the case?

sfifs|3 years ago

Not OP but Many many instances of corrupt leaders or leaders with unpopular policies/poor governance being thrown out of power in elections peacefully. If anything, the fatalism & inability of Americans to change their political establishment tends to be puzzling for us.

01acheru|3 years ago

They are probably Indian and feel it a lot.

rusticpenn|3 years ago

I would agree, many Indians, the democratic majority support this.

sockaddr|3 years ago

This is probably the most ridiculous statement I've read all week. It's only Wednesday, but still.