top | item 34857043

(no title)

ominous | 3 years ago

> Any case, the earlier commenter is not assuming cis people are terrible and transphobic and whatever.

It's worse than that. It assumes x people, by virtue of belonging to x group, actively perpetuate x-group-favouring-biases.

Otherwise, your comment is reasonable.

> degrading

I disagree with the degrading, as I am talking directly to the commenter by showing them how I react to what they commented. Did you miss a "hello dear x, (...), best, ominous"?

> patronizing (telling people how they should behave), (...), and from a clear place of closed-mindedness

I see what you mean, but I have no problems with that. I am not advocating that one is patronizing nor close-minded, nor do I consider myself as such. But if the reaction to "whites together are oppressors excluding the oppressed and perpetuating a status quo that favours whites" cannot be patronizing, what reaction do you allow?

It won't surprise you that from the countless impressions this "signal" for progressivism made on my screens, I reply to very little. This Sunday morning I took some time to do it. You read it, and start to focus on the form of it, the timing, what it may mean, etc, as if you saw me engaging this all the time. The poster I replied to, on the other hand, is like that full time. Read this bit [0]. The user is educated in these matters, backed by scholarship. It's a whole worldview. It's not the intuitively "You'll be making constant calculations on whether it's safe to show public displays of affection with your partner, or simply appear an act like you want to. The fears are exaggerated of course (we are all creatures of caution), but not unfounded, depending on where you live." that creatures of caution have, but rather a whole domain of knowledge that accumulates justifications for behaviours.

It isn't a scared person hiding in the comfort of a safe space. It is a culture learning to hate.

> So yes, short-term, it's nice to escape to a place where you don't have to do that. Long-term, it's healthier to not autosegregate, both for the queer and non-queer person. It helps normalise things.

I agree.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34856039

discuss

order

No comments yet.