top | item 35111990

(no title)

msp_yc | 3 years ago

From the paper: "The purpose of writing is to convey ideas to the reader. The purpose of formatting is to make the document easier to read, not to look pretty."

I find that thesis a bit reductive. For technical writing, I can agree - the purpose is to convey ideas. But, there is a whole other class of writing that isn't intended to convey ideas, but _emotion_.

Also from the paper: "The purpose of document design is to display the logical structure of the document through its formatting, thereby making it easier to read."

Again, there's a whole other class of documents whose formatting takes precedence over the logical information, intended to evoke emotion.

Not to take away from Lamport, who is seriously brilliant, but there appears to be a blind spot here.

discuss

order

No comments yet.