[platers]

What if you could upload a photo of your hand and the RL agent learns the optimal fingering for your hand?

[john61]

My taste, my pianistict abilities, my arm, shoulder and body movements and my musical idea for the interpretation and imagination of the sound of the piece can not be seen in a photo of my hand. Not even a good teacher can give you a finished perfect fingering for you, I doubt that a dumb machine can do any better, especially if it plays that bad as the examples sound in comparison to a even beginner human. You have to find the fingering out for yourself and this is part of the great joy of playing / learning piano.

[montag]

It's not quite that simple; everyone has different dexterity and innervation (how strong is the wiring between your pinky and ring finger?)

[martyvis]

What if the AI gets to see you playing sample pieces or even if you have say a weighted keyboard that it gets to see the forces you can apply? I mean I've seen the Australian Sports Academy do all sorts of video and biomechanical instrumentation of elite athletes with the aim of improving their technique and provide a customised training regime. I can't see why it can't be used in music performance which in many ways is just as much athleticism as it is art.