top | item 3546524

Hacker News rips off Reddit or so Mashable claims...

15 points| f4stjack | 14 years ago |mashable.com | reply

Don't know whether this is a repost or not but... What do you say people? Far as I can see, HN looks different, simpler and conceptually it doesn't try to include everything on this earth...

15 comments

order
[+] jacquesm|14 years ago|reply
Maybe someone should tell mashable about slashdot?
[+] edd|14 years ago|reply
This 'rip off' was much more evident before Reddit got big (the first time) and redesigned the voting buttons. Before that the designs were almost identical.
[+] xlance|14 years ago|reply
Reddit is open source and was a Y combinator startup.I don't see the problem here.
[+] bdfh42|14 years ago|reply
The News (Social bookmarking) pages on our web site are pretty similar as well. Clean minimalist layouts with similar functionality are going to look similar whatever the style influences - well apart from the CSS.
[+] navs|14 years ago|reply
a certain nerdy demographic

Use of the word 'nerd' from a tech blog?

[+] nddrylliog|14 years ago|reply
Why not? They use it at the congress...

Feels insulting every time, but it seems to be common practice.

[+] webwanderings|14 years ago|reply
I like both, it doesn't give a sh* about social networking, doesn't emphasize users over content, which is good.
[+] rsanchez1|14 years ago|reply
Peter Pachel probably stopped by recently and noticed how much the comments are becoming like Reddit, and felt compelled to make the connection and post it on Mashable.
[+] Torn|14 years ago|reply
Quite funny seeing as Reddit was YC-incubated and was clearly inspired by HN
[+] steventruong|14 years ago|reply
While Reddit was part of YC, it launched in 2005. HN didn't launch till 2007.
[+] gazrogers|14 years ago|reply
I just checked the wayback machine and Reddit appears first in mid 2005, HN in Feb 2007 (though the article with id 1 here seems to have been posted in October 2006). It's fair to say that Reddit wasn't inspired by HN.
[+] bleakgadfly|14 years ago|reply
Wikipedia says HN was created in 2007 and Reddit in 2005.