top | item 36074531

(no title)

cnelsenmilt | 2 years ago

Thorough and enforced training requirements for gun ownership I think would shift a lot of opinions from the somewhat opposed to the accepting column.

discuss

order

bmelton|2 years ago

This is only a tenable position to hold if you _also_ accept educational requirements to exercise other rights. E.g., the right to vote.

The Supreme Court has held that such requirements to exercise a fundamental right are inherently unconstitutional and discriminatory.

Because rights are held to the standard of scrutiny, the only way to diminish the protections afforded by the second amendment is to lower the standard of scrutiny, which opens the door to two scenarios: either the 2nd amendment is deemed unpopular enough of a right that it warrants diminished protections, which yields the prospect of any right becoming unpopular and protections similarly diminished, or none of the enumerated rights deserve the robust protections that the second amendment provides, which imperils protections on rights we may care more about, like voting (which is not even constitutionally enumerated,) speech, etc.