[onetrickwolf]

I mean why are power lines not locked up and buried underground secured locked steel cages?

Because some things work better with trust vs convoluted security.

I think this is something a lot of computer nerds don't get (myself included at one point). It's almost like if something can be accessed we are allowed to access it and it's the fault of the person securing it. But a lot of our society works on trust and I think we'd live in a much more difficult world if everything had to be secure enough to resist any attack.

If this thing was connected to the internet I get it, but you already need physical access to the meter why add another layer of security on top of that? If someone has wants to mess up your power and they have physical access there's plenty of ways they can do it without wireless communication.

[bayindirh]

I would just add a simple layer of device-id based password generation function which is hard to reverse engineer. The devices used by authorized people would auto-generate it and will be transparent to them, yet it'll prevent many people from getting in. Add a rate-limiter on top of it, and it's impractical to brute force it.

If Philips can secure its SoniCare brush heads this way to prevent tampering and counterfeiting, a utility company or meter producer which enables a much more important infrastructure can be a little more mindful about what they are doing.

Other than that I agree 100% to your viewpoint.

[InitialBP]

Definitely agree with you here. The parent has a very valid point about not always over-securing things that don't need to be secured, but physical line cutting and wireless shutoff are very different threats.

Someone walking around your neighborhood cutting every single electric line on the side of a house, risking electric shock and trespassing on your private land is much more likely to get caught than somebody rolling through your neighborhood with a flipper zero and a high power antenna turning off all of your meters.

If someone had a grudge against you, and they started to "release the magic smoke" from your meter once a week and the power company is upset with you and your HVAC system doesn't work anymore, in addition to the fact that the compressor in your AC is toast because of someone energizing and de-energizing the circuit so rapidly. Now you are out thousands of dollars and, on top of all that, no matter how many cameras you put up, you'll have a hard time figuring out who's doing it.

[salawat]

Which is exactly how you end up with more etrash when a company goes out of business.

Also, you've just made replacement/repair/support far more complicated and dangerous for everyone than it need be. You must be 10% smarter than any piece of equipment you are operating to safely use it, and be "ahead of the machine".

I truly believe we have suffered greatly as a civilization for our willingness to lose sight of that, and to have allowed the siren call of "abstraction" to charm us into making things so absurdly complicated that short of neverending population growth to bring into existence more people to solve all the new problems people have created, one is hard pressed to even read everything necessary to understand why most things are the way they are.

[soupfordummies]

Very good insight here. This is something I’ve been thinking a lot about.

Case in point the electric substation attacks early this year.

Or on a micro scale, just walking into a store, taking what you want and then walking out.

I don’t think anyone really wants to live in a society that is fully secure but to not have that we need to stop the breakdown of trust.

Arguably, the only reason we have society and not total anarchy is because everyone kinda tacitly agrees to “act right”

[xeromal]

Yeah, a lot of this infrastructure was built on a trust-based society so we're having to slowly learn that isn't possible in our current culture and population size. It's sad.