Unpopular opinion, but I like the Magic Mouse and Magic Keyboard!
I try other Mouses but always return to the Apple products.
Trying to get other Mouses to have the same acceleration and tracking as you he Magic Mouse eludes me!
The thing with the Magic Mouse is the touch sensor on top! Being able to swipe and scroll horizontally and vertically is so ingrained that I miss it when switching.
Adding a TouchID sensor to the side of the Apple Magic Mouse would be super useful!
I don’t have a Magic Keyboard with TouchID yet, so I’m constantly reaching over to MacBook keyboard. I feel like if my thumb could just connect with the TouchID sensor on the side of a Magic Mouse, there’s be a lot less friction in the security UI!
I’m inspired to also try a trackpad given the enthusiasm shown in the comments here!
The magic keyboard is ok. The layout is subpar and it lacks a tiny bit of travel for a thin-style keyboard (.2 mm extra would do it I think), but overall it is nicely built, reliable and easy to clean. Going to that from a thinkpad keyboard was a bit rough though. I wonder if people who love it have ever used a good keyboard.
The magic mouse is the worst mouse I have used so far, precisely because of the touch area. I tried for a while to adapt to it and developed severe RSI. I event went through the “I must be holding it wrong” pattern like the apple fanboy I am, to no avail. I suspect it comes down to me having the wrong shape of hand. Luckily logitech makes some excellent mice, and I can map the thumb buttons to the gestures I used most on the magic mouse.
This is a mandatory install on macOS for me (one of many).
The suite of extra software utilities required to make the base OS usable is ridiculous, but I'm glad to see open source maintainers working to keep my mouse working.
Unpopular opinion perhaps, but as someone who's bouncing between all three big desktop platforms pretty regularly, cursor acceleration is a total non-issue. I adjust to the difference so quickly that I don't even notice a difference.
I'm glad that Sonoma is adding the checkbox to turn it off for those who need it but it's never been a bother for me.
Not to take away from this app, but I’ve been using Mos https://mos.caldis.me for a couple of years now and it’s been just enough to mitigate the faults I had with default mouse settings in macOS.
This is what I've been looking for for such a long time.
The maximum speed that can be configured using the built in tools for both mouse and trackpad is way too slow for my liking.
In the past I used MagicPrefs to do this, but that sadly doesn't work anymore. This is the first time I'm able to do this again, and with a free tool too! Thanks a lot for submitting this.
I ended up having to pay(!) to re-enable middle clicking after magicprefs stopped working at some point in the macos upgrade race. I bought this. https://middleclick.app/
I've long looked for a good mouse utility for Mac that can disable mouse acceleration, modify scroll wheel behavior, etc. This one even saves preferences per-device which I find very useful.
I’m eager to try this out, but you might also want to check out Steermouse[1], which is a utility it took me years longer to discover than it should have.
I’m not sure how it stacks up to this open source project, but it’s definitely been worth the license cost to me over the years.
Can’t use macOS&Magic Mouse on 2x27” without cranking up the acceleration. Been using https://plentycom.jp/en/cursorsense/ for 10 years.
Will try this, seems more maintained.
I've used Smooze [1] in the past. It has a ton of features, but I really just need it for turning off mouse acceleration and making the scroll wheel usable. Glad to see an open source option.
I would prefer it show me the homebrew command in addition to a copy to clipboard button instead of just the button so I have to _trust_ what you're having me paste.
It's `brew install --cask linearmouse` for those wondering.
Are you a windows/linux user that finds Mac mice always feel weirdly slow or "wrong"? This fixes it, and is frequently updated. Mandatory new mac install item for me.
Nice! I've been using Mac Mouse Fix (https://mousefix.org/), which is also open source, to handle inverting my mouse wheel and remapping the back/forward buttons, but LinearMouse looks quite a bit more featureful.
The lack of mouse acceleration in Windows is what make it feel, to me, clunky and slow. I know it’s a function of what you grew up with/are used to but it’s interesting to see. Personally I like being able to flick my mouse across the screen without having to pick up my mouse—enables faster work.
> The lack of mouse acceleration in Windows is what make it feel, to m
Windows has had built-in acceleration since Windows XP (maybe 2000?) - it's the "Enhance pointer precision" option in the (classic) Mouse control panel.
There's also an acceleration curve you can customize, but there's no built-in GUI editor, but the data's all in the HKCU\Control Panel\Mouse registry keys.
I've had my touchpad randomly stop working. Sometimes a restart fixed it, sometimes it required a deep dive into driver land. Something so basic that should just work.
As an aside, I had just started working on a tool to do that since all I want is to have natural scrolling on my trackpad but regular scrolling on my mouse. Will have to take a look if this goes with the a11y route or the custom driver path.
Does anyone know of a tool that can emulate the pointer inertia you'd find with a trackball, but on a trackpad? This way, you could 'launch' the pointer across the screen. As a long-time trackball user, I believe this feature would be incredibly useful.
I've kept a minimized macos preference window open for months now so that I can switch the mode when I'm on the go. This app takes care of that one use case pretty well and just made my life slightly better.
Apple's idea of "natural scrolling direction" is insane.
Scrolling with a touchpad and scrolling with with a mouse wheel are simply different things - the natural direction is simply different for both.
That’s 100 % subjective. There’s not a single reason why sliding your finger on a mechanical movable surface should behave differently than sliding it on a touch sensitive surface. You’re used to it behaving differently and that’s fine, but I prefer to have the same behavior for both and neither of us is right or wrong.
Interesting. I just got finished working on some JavaScript to auto detect two-finger trackpad scroll vs a physical mousewheel and wondered why this kind of thing isn’t built into the OS.
I'm still using Logitech Options+ when I dock my MacBook Air into my big screen and use an MX Anywhere. Last I checked, none of these utilities enable click-and-hold to pan.
I've been using "Scroll Reverser" for years to let me have Natural Scrolling on my trackpad but not my mouse. I'll have to check this out as an alternative.
Same for me, long time user of https://github.com/pilotmoon/Scroll-Reverser
Just curious, when you have a tool that does such a precise small single task, and does it perfectly, why would you bother installing an alternative? What I thought when reading this post was more like "I already have a perfect solution, I don't need another perfect solution", so just curious if you think I'm missing something by thinking like this?
would be great if it also offered middle-click emulation like other utilities do for those cross-platform programs that think everyone has a three-button mouse
firecall|2 years ago
I try other Mouses but always return to the Apple products.
Trying to get other Mouses to have the same acceleration and tracking as you he Magic Mouse eludes me!
The thing with the Magic Mouse is the touch sensor on top! Being able to swipe and scroll horizontally and vertically is so ingrained that I miss it when switching.
Adding a TouchID sensor to the side of the Apple Magic Mouse would be super useful!
I don’t have a Magic Keyboard with TouchID yet, so I’m constantly reaching over to MacBook keyboard. I feel like if my thumb could just connect with the TouchID sensor on the side of a Magic Mouse, there’s be a lot less friction in the security UI!
I’m inspired to also try a trackpad given the enthusiasm shown in the comments here!
Joeri|2 years ago
The magic mouse is the worst mouse I have used so far, precisely because of the touch area. I tried for a while to adapt to it and developed severe RSI. I event went through the “I must be holding it wrong” pattern like the apple fanboy I am, to no avail. I suspect it comes down to me having the wrong shape of hand. Luckily logitech makes some excellent mice, and I can map the thumb buttons to the gestures I used most on the magic mouse.
alwillis|2 years ago
I've always liked the Magic Mouse.
> The thing with the Magic Mouse is the touch sensor on top! Being able to swipe and scroll horizontally and vertically
This is such an underrated feature; I use it constantly.
But there's more it can do; Better Touch Tool lets you configure gestures to your heart's content [1].
[1]: https://folivora.ai
troupo|2 years ago
- you can't rest your fingers on it. When you use it, you have to keep your finger(s) raised
- if an app/game uses middle button, you can't use that
tipsytoad|2 years ago
_ZeD_|2 years ago
(Sorry, but I can't stand Apple hardware... I find it very crappy)
idle_zealot|2 years ago
jonny_eh|2 years ago
Would you mind expanding on that? I'm not sure what I'd improve about my touchpad experience on my Mac.
frou_dh|2 years ago
ayemel|2 years ago
ahstilde|2 years ago
tambourine_man|2 years ago
Use Windows or Linux. Good luck and have fun!
kitsunesoba|2 years ago
I'm glad that Sonoma is adding the checkbox to turn it off for those who need it but it's never been a bother for me.
yoyopa|2 years ago
jonwest|2 years ago
lode|2 years ago
The maximum speed that can be configured using the built in tools for both mouse and trackpad is way too slow for my liking.
In the past I used MagicPrefs to do this, but that sadly doesn't work anymore. This is the first time I'm able to do this again, and with a free tool too! Thanks a lot for submitting this.
0x0|2 years ago
dang|2 years ago
LinearMouse – A minimal app to get rid of scrolling acceleration on macOS - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27485051 - June 2021 (76 comments)
cowjan|2 years ago
blairbeckwith|2 years ago
I’m not sure how it stacks up to this open source project, but it’s definitely been worth the license cost to me over the years.
[1] https://plentycom.jp/en/steermouse/
sorahn|2 years ago
aPoCoMiLogin|2 years ago
reboot81|2 years ago
mehlmao|2 years ago
[1] https://smooze.co/
baq|2 years ago
"You're holding it wrong" taken to absolute mastery.
hk1337|2 years ago
It's `brew install --cask linearmouse` for those wondering.
bloqs|2 years ago
astockwell|2 years ago
callahad|2 years ago
ayemel|2 years ago
DaiPlusPlus|2 years ago
Windows has had built-in acceleration since Windows XP (maybe 2000?) - it's the "Enhance pointer precision" option in the (classic) Mouse control panel.
There's also an acceleration curve you can customize, but there's no built-in GUI editor, but the data's all in the HKCU\Control Panel\Mouse registry keys.
unknown|2 years ago
[deleted]
gibolt|2 years ago
I am not aware of any trackpad failures on Mac.
strongpigeon|2 years ago
As an aside, I had just started working on a tool to do that since all I want is to have natural scrolling on my trackpad but regular scrolling on my mouse. Will have to take a look if this goes with the a11y route or the custom driver path.
Edit: looks like this modifies CGEvent
pb060|2 years ago
mike31fr|2 years ago
tlhunter|2 years ago
Pesthuf|2 years ago
Toutouxc|2 years ago
That’s 100 % subjective. There’s not a single reason why sliding your finger on a mechanical movable surface should behave differently than sliding it on a touch sensitive surface. You’re used to it behaving differently and that’s fine, but I prefer to have the same behavior for both and neither of us is right or wrong.
turtlebits|2 years ago
shove|2 years ago
akerr|2 years ago
donatj|2 years ago
mike31fr|2 years ago
jb1991|2 years ago
olgeni|2 years ago
idle_zealot|2 years ago
kidfiji|2 years ago
eshack94|2 years ago
Moldoteck|2 years ago
jnsie|2 years ago
mig39|2 years ago
vehemenz|2 years ago
rcarr|2 years ago
drixer|2 years ago