top | item 37127684

What could Universal Early Childcare look like?

25 points| throwaway33381 | 2 years ago |dchung.substack.com

61 comments

order

hammock|2 years ago

If it looks anything like government and union-run public schools, not good.

For example, Chicago public school teachers get paid more than any other school system in the US (from $60k for a new teacher to $114k for the most experienced) and the schools have some of, if not the worst educational outcomes: in 2019, 1 in 4 7th graders could not read at grade level

tptacek|2 years ago

CPS teachers are not in fact paid more than every other school system; NYC and LA pay more on average, and if you adjust for cost of living, Cleveland is a better deal. Meanwhile: the big sticking points with the CPS unions --- of which I am not a fan --- are class size and support staff, which are not pocket-lining issues for the teachers.

Contusion3532|2 years ago

Maybe the problems in Chicago's education are outside of the scope of the teachers?

osigurdson|2 years ago

Agree. Give governments money, get less back now with strings attached.

wernercd|2 years ago

[deleted]

ta8645|2 years ago

It could look a lot like a nuclear family. With a healthy economy that doesn't require both parents to work.

anon291|2 years ago

For many people, it's a choice to work. We're part of a very close knit church in which there is a wide range of incomes and everyone makes it work. That's because the moms (it's usually the moms who are not working although there are a few dads) make it a point to actually organize the community. That means lots of shared activities; lots of shared child care; shared meals; etc. Unfortunately, when you stop doing the work of community, everything becomes more expensive. That's the ultimate reason why day care et al is so expensive. It's not just that you have to pay others to watch your children; it's that you have to pay one set of people to watch your children, then another set to cook your food, then another set to be part of a community, etc.

As a case in point, my daughters attend a free mom's preschool (a few times a week) instead of us paying thousands of dollars. We haven't bought much clothes or furniture for them because there are endless amounts of hand-me-downs.

Unfortunately, as a whole, American civil institutions (and really worldwide) have declined. It's not just churches or marriage that has seen record reductions in membership. It's actually not even a crisis in religion that we're witnessing although many want to castigate it as that.

Rather, all social groups are in decline, whether that be the small social group of marriage, or the large social group of the extended family, or the even wider social group of a community club. Bowling clubs, fraternal organizations, athletic clubs, etc are all in decline.

oh_sigh|2 years ago

So basically one person, usually the woman, gets to not have a personal life.

CreRecombinase|2 years ago

How might one go about making the nuclear family a universal?

s1artibartfast|2 years ago

It could look like deregulation of child care and simplification of small business registration.

It could look like a young child income tax credit

voz_|2 years ago

At one point, I was bombarded by this topic. Reddit, NPR, Twitter, every single voice left leaning voice was beating this drum.

Why? We didn’t accomplish universal healthcare, women’s rights are under attack, climate change is unaddressed, nazis are growing in boldness and volume.

We, in the left, have failed in most of our latest crusades (certainly the ones in my life) because the regressive powers are entrenched and organized. Is this really the time to change focus again??

dudul|2 years ago

I like that you used the word "crusades". Says a lot about how some people on the left view themselves.

wernercd|2 years ago

The problem is you think the left isn't full of regressive powers.

You, in the left, have failed because you're guilty of what you claim others are doing and do so while calling anyone you disagree with "nazi's" and "racists". making those "slurs" worth less than the promises you're failing to kill us all with.