top | item 37409623

(no title)

consilient | 2 years ago

e/acc is an internet meme. The underlying ideological group, to the extent that there is one, is the "reactionary modernism"/"Californian Ideology"/"New Right"/"neoreactionary" cluster.

My impression is that for Scott they're what he calls a "fargroup": weird and bad in theory, but not salient enough to provoke a real response in practice. The way modern people feel about Genghis Khan. But I have very mixed feelings about Scott and extremely negative feelings about neoreactionaries, so take that with a grain of salt.

discuss

order

giraffe_lady|2 years ago

My impression is that they're what scott calls "my dinner guests." Seriously I cannot find anything in his writing that is incompatible with those movements and beliefs. If one of them wanted to get as much "mainstream" acceptance as possible they would write carefully about exactly the things he writes about, leaving out exactly the things he leaves out. I am completely convinced this is his project.

consilient|2 years ago

> My impression is that they're what scott calls "my dinner guests."

Yes, he's pathologically friendly towards anyone to his right: part and parcel of not taking them that seriously.

> Seriously I cannot find anything in his writing that is incompatible with those movements and beliefs.

He's a centrist neoliberal, ala Matt Yglesias. In some ways the two groups are mirror images. Paraphrasing someone, though I don't remember who:

capitalism ostensibly has two functions:

- Concentrate power in the hands of individuals who successfully "move fast and break things"

- Efficiently allocate resources through impersonal market mechanisms.

These are not fully compatible. Neoliberals aren't exactly anti-oligarch, and neoreactionaries aren't exactly anti-market, but when the two tendencies clash they're on opposite sides.

Scott doesn't hate people like Thiel, which marks him as not-left, but he's clearly not interested in doing away with liberal democracy and making him CEO of America.