I do too, I made this [0] 3 years before Svelte existed. But I don't think the "pretend it isn't" makes any sense, I actually like React more than Svelte for many reasons, but magic compilers and templates are two big ones.
>But I don't think the "pretend it isn't" makes any sense
Well, let me expand a bit more. React's pitch is that view is a function of state, and essentially designed around the idea of an immutable state which re-renders everything when changed. It then offered some APIs to allow fine-tuning of rendering via hooks which either ties with data changes or some rendering life-cycle. To me the API screams of stubborn refusal to let go of the "view as a function of state" mantra: When you encounter a scenario where it breaks the mantra, lets add another lever to handle it. This lever also has to be pulled by you the developer, and it is up to you to know when to do it.
>I actually like React more than Svelte for many reasons, but magic compilers and templates are two big ones.
I don't really have an issue with compilers. They are the accepted magic that bridges between language for people and language for machines. The ideal language might be something that is functional and immutable language that it is easy for us to read, but compiles to the optimized, imperative updates that machine can run well.
I'd probably like React better if it had a compile layer on top of its more functional parts?
As for templates, JSX is probably the one great thing that came out of React. It is no wonder that many other frameworks are embracing JSX, but none of them are really forking the idea of hooks.
nwienert|2 years ago
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHTYHm6qLFY&t=11s
SinParadise|2 years ago
>But I don't think the "pretend it isn't" makes any sense
Well, let me expand a bit more. React's pitch is that view is a function of state, and essentially designed around the idea of an immutable state which re-renders everything when changed. It then offered some APIs to allow fine-tuning of rendering via hooks which either ties with data changes or some rendering life-cycle. To me the API screams of stubborn refusal to let go of the "view as a function of state" mantra: When you encounter a scenario where it breaks the mantra, lets add another lever to handle it. This lever also has to be pulled by you the developer, and it is up to you to know when to do it.
>I actually like React more than Svelte for many reasons, but magic compilers and templates are two big ones.
I don't really have an issue with compilers. They are the accepted magic that bridges between language for people and language for machines. The ideal language might be something that is functional and immutable language that it is easy for us to read, but compiles to the optimized, imperative updates that machine can run well.
I'd probably like React better if it had a compile layer on top of its more functional parts?
As for templates, JSX is probably the one great thing that came out of React. It is no wonder that many other frameworks are embracing JSX, but none of them are really forking the idea of hooks.